Fake news from Israel: Trump needs permission

Tuvia Brodie,

לבן ריק
לבן ריק
צילום: ערוץ 7
Tuvia Brodie
Tuvia Brodie has a PhD from the University of Pittsburgh under the name Philip Brodie. He has worked for the University of Pittsburgh, Chatham College and American Express. He and his wife made aliyah in 2010. All of his children have followed. He believes in Israel's right to exist. He believes that the words of Tanach (the Jewish Bible) are meant for us. His blog address is http://tuviainil.blogspot.com He usually publishes 3-4 times a week on his blog and 1-3 times at Arutz Sheva. Please check the blog regularly for new posts.

Today, we report again about fake news from Israel. But this fake news isn’t the ordinary kind of fakery you find in America’s mainstream media.
In America, fake news hurts America (Dana Blanton, "Fox news poll: fake news hurting US", foxnews, January 24, 2017). This fakery is different. It's fakery-to-make-a-point. 

It’s satire. It’s aim is to reveal a truth, not harm a country, a culture or a politician.

Today’s satire focuses on US objection to Israel’s building apartments for Jews in Israel. The essay below is fakery. It turns reality up-side down so you can understand how outrageous the real reality really is.

The essay comes from preoccupiedterritory (“Trump Envoy In Talks With Bibi Over Whether US May Build In Washington”, March 27, 2017). It's an essay that reminds us how Israel Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu feels he must seek permission from the US to build homes for Jews in Israeli 'settlements' ("Netanyahu: still in talks with Trump team over settlements",breitbart, March 15, 2017). I have edited/rewritten this fake news story to fit my format. You can read the original at preoccupiedterritory. Remember, this is satire:

Subtitle: US and Israeli administrations have clashed previously on American construction projects built on land that was taken from native American peoples.

Washington, March 27 – Political and diplomatic sensitivities have heated up regarding construction on Washington, DC land allegedly stolen from indigenous peoples. US President Donald Trump has become cautious before his administration approves development projects in the US’ declared capital, White House sources reported today. Trump has dispatched a special envoy to negotiate with Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu over the proposed construction.

Jonathan Greenblatt spent the weekend in Jerusalem clarifying for Prime Minister Netanyahu what are Trump’s intentions regarding several construction projects which are slated to occupy land the United States is said to have taken from native tribes. Construction of that nature has riled indigenous-American rights activists in the past, and the President aims to reach an understanding with Netanyahu over the projects in order to prevent Israeli objections to the building, objections that might carry diplomatic or economic consequences for the US.
American officials with knowledge of the talks reported that no progress had been made on an understanding. “These are the closest of allies, and allies can disagree. The key is frank discussion and the realization that the friendship, the alliance, is stronger than any one issue, however strategic,” explained State Department spokesman Mark Toner. “But we and Mr, Netanyahu will continue our talks so that we do not end up advancing any construction that he feels is contrary to his interests. It’s the dialogue here that is critical, regardless of the specifics of any understanding we reach.”

US and Israeli administrations have clashed previously on American construction projects built on land that was taken from native-American peoples, with claims of genocide and ethnic cleansing often characterizing desc‎riptions of those events. While the US has managed to escape UN condemnation or sanctions in response to those activities, successive presidential administrations have worked to maintain friendly relations with other influential countries such as Israel to prevent such resolutions from being brought to the UN Security Council.

Some US lawmakers, however, bristle because the US President allows another country’s policies to exert effective veto power over what these US lawmakers consider domestic matters. Representative Keith Ellison (D-MN) argued that the US should push ahead with its development plans as a matter of national sovereignty, regardless of what other nations think of the legitimacy of such moves.

“Now is the time to build, build, build,” insisted Ellison. “We’ve never had a friend in Jerusalem as strong as Netanyahu, and if we don’t take advantage of this opportunity to assert our rights to all of this land, how can we ever expect the world to accept we belong here at all? We shouldn’t be begging Bibi for permission. He appreciates strong leaders. Our relationship will weather whatever trouble our domestic decisions may or may not precipitate. I doubt we’ll have an Israeli administration as friendly as this one for a long time, if ever.”

Yes, this story is a fake. Any people or places whose names look familiar here bear no resemblance to real people or existing places. So far, it’s only the US that pressures Israel, not the other way around.  So far, Israel Prime Minister has registered no objections (that we know about) regarding any Trump administration building plans for Washington, DC.

Of course, tomorrow could bring a new day—along with a new outlook.


Don’t go away. This story about Israel has just begun.