This article initially incorrectly identified the organizers of the event in question as the Union of Jewish Students (UJS). In fact, it was a Kings JSoc event and had no connection to the UJS. The article has been amended to reflect this.
Controversy erupted last week following an event held by the Jewish Society at Kings College in London, after questions about Israel were silenced and renowned author Rabbi Shmuel Boteach’s lecture was cut off abruptly.
The moderators for the event offered the explanation that Israel, which Rabbi Boteach had spoken about during his lecture, was not to be discussed, as part of the JSoc policy of having only topics relating to Judaism being allowed for discussion at the lecture.
Rabbi Boteach described the incident on his personal website:
I focused my remarks on Israeli democracy and the ways in which it could be a model for the autocratic Arab states of the region. Israel is the great hope for the spread of human rights throughout the Middle East.
As I spoke, I could see my hosts growing restless and the discomfiture on their faces surprised me. I was in for a bigger shock, however, when my hosts stopped me mid-lecture and said that they were opening the floor for questions. I am always happy to respond to questions, friendly or hostile, but I have rarely been interrupted so abruptly by the people who invited me to speak.
When I asked for an explanation, I was told by the president of the organization, a young man wearing a yarmulke, that the Jewish Society has a policy against speaking about Israel. The group, he said was non-political and focused on “Jewish subjects.”
Israel not a Jewish subject? I was dumbfounded. It was as if Israel had become the Voldemort of nations, the country that dare not be named.
When I recovered from the shock, I asked if I should speak about lox and bagels, klezmer music or Manischewitz wine. My sarcasm seemed to go right over my hosts’ heads. For them, Israel and Judaism were unrelated. I asked if the murder of Israeli citizens in countless terror attacks over the past month was likewise a “political issue,” or one of human rights. I was told by one of the students that these things needs not be put in boxes. Worse, I sensed that these students, who had enough pride in their heritage, and commitment to their faith, to wear their yarmulkes in public, had become so cowed by the omnipresent hostility and bullying on and off British campuses that they were afraid to engage in a dialogue about Israel.
Rabbi Boteach spoke to Arutz Sheva about the incident and what the underlying issues that have come to light because of it are.
“Once I started speaking about Israel they expressed their displeasure, and said that they would not accept any questions about Israel as it was a political subject and that they were strictly a Jewish group,” said Boteach.
While Rabbi Boteach was shocked at the incident he claims that the story is not what happened, but rather the underlying reasons as to why it happened. “The issue is not what happened to me and what transpired in Kings College,” Boteach said. “The real issue is what is the policy both in Kings College and across England.”
“It is not my intention to create a conflict,” said Rabbi Boteach, “but the [current] president of the Jewish Society contacted me via my Facebook page and said that indeed the policy is not to discuss Israel. And this is a scary position for a student group to take.”
So why would the Jewish Society refuse to have Israel be a subject discussed by Jewish societies universities in England? Is it because they want the university to be a ‘safe space’? Or perhaps it is because they want it to remain the place of Israel societies, or it offends people? Perhaps it is a toxic subject due to the type of character assassination that Israel endures on campus in specific and in Britain in general? Whatever the reason may be, Rabbi Boteach says that the policy is “frightening”.
“To purge Israel from Jewishness is quite frightening,” he warned. “Do we want to return to a pre-Zionist time when Israel did not enjoy unqualified Jewish support? I shudder to think what the ramifications of that would be. Especially now,” he added.
Rabbi Boteach said that the timing of such a move could not be worse. “At a time when Jewish life is being cheapened to the point that US Secretaries of State can offer rationalizations as to why terror attacks are taking place against Jews, this is the time to stand up and support Israel.”
Rabbi Boteach related tot he difficult position that Jewish students finds themselves in. “I’m not saying that it is easy, and I am not here to pass judgement on the student union. I am saying that whatever they think the justification of the policy is, it is absolutely unjustified.”
“It is not for me to surmise the reason for the policy, whether they think it offends people, or that it is toxic or that it will cause students not to come. Whatever it may be, I am not imputing their motives. But let us recall that these were the polices of student groups just before the Second World War as well.”
Citing the historical precedent during the American Presidential terms of Roosevelt and Truman, Boteach compared the situation to that of Rabbi Stephen Wise and Peter Bergson. Wise believed that the Jewish community should stay silent and not rock the boat in the US. Peter Bergson (a.k.a Hillel Kook) came to the US saw what was happening and smashed every door down that he could until he succeeded in rescuing 200,000 Hungarian Jews.
Boteach used this historical example and others, to illustrate how “that there is no reason to stay silent on this issue. Silence never serves the purpose of saving human lives when people are dying.” He added that the delegitimization of Israel leads directly into the devaluing of Jewish life.
“Once Israel is made out to be a pariah state, then it has no right to defend itself. Then it is an aggressor it is a country that persecutes people. And that is when the world has no sympathy for Jewish life taken in acts of terror. Such a move would even allow the world to find justification for it. Stephen Wise’s name lives now in infamy because he was wrong,” said Boteach.
Boteach went one step further stating that the organization, which prides itself on its democratic stance, has an obligation to stand up for Israel. “The purpose of democracy is to speak out against miscarriages of justice. The way that Israel is being treated in Europe as well as much of the Western World is absolutely a miscarriage of Justice and it must be protested.”
“Forget about pro-Israel advocacy, Israel itself was being silenced as a topic for discussion. A Jewish discussion. What could be more Jewish than Israel? To have the very topic silenced, and by students. Jewish students? Students of all kinds, not just Jewish should be the vanguard of the pro-israel talk on campus. And the vanguard of opening discussions, even difficult discussions, not closing them,” Boteach exclaimed.
In a press interview in the UK a representative defended the comment and the policy, he noted, and therefore seemingly this is not an isolated incident.
“We have a responsibility to do the right thing,” Boteach admonished. “Regardless of how impactful we may be. We have to do the right thing. We have to stand up for our nation, especially when we are under this type of assault. The need is there and every Jew is involved, no matter how unwilling they wish to be.
"We are blessed to have a Jewish state after 2,000 years, and we have to stand up for it. Will we always be effective? Perhaps not. But what does that have to do with our obligation? We have to do what is right.”
In response to the incident, the Union of Jewish Students (UJS) - which represents JSocs throughout the UK but was not involved in the event in question - issued the following response:
"A last minute request for Rabbi Boteach to speak at Kings was well received by Jewish student volunteers. Rabbi Boteach spoke for 30 minutes about a range of subjects including Israel.
"Jewish students at many campuses in London have found that combatting the deligitimisation of Israel with separate Israel societies is the most effective method for their environment.
"Jewish students are extremely active at Kings in standing up for Israel and ensuring a balanced debate. Last year, during Israeli Apartheid Week, Jewish students across three London institutions, including Kings, ran the Piece 2 Peace campaign; an initiative that engaged over 4000 students in constructive dialogue around the conflict.
"UJS works closely with students across the country in determining the best way to fight the delegitimisation of Israel on each individual campus. Israel engagement is a core value of UJS and an example of this includes three unique trips to Israel in just a few weeks. "