Canadian court: Judea and Samaria not part of Israel

Canadian court rules wine made in Judea and Samaria cannot be labelled as made in Israel, 'no dispute settlements not part of Israel.'

AFP,

Buying wine at a supermarket (illustrative)
Buying wine at a supermarket (illustrative)
iStock

A Canadian court on Monday ruled that it was "false, misleading and deceptive" to label wines made in Jewish communities in Judea and Samaria as a "Product of Israel."

Canada's Federal Court had been asked to rule in the case of David Kattenburg, the child of Holocaust survivors who disagreed with a decision by the Canadian government's Food Inspection Agency to allow the labels.
Kattenburg, who criticized Israel's policies, argued that such labeling "facilitates Israel's de facto annexation of large portions of the West Bank," according to the court ruling.

The CFIA had defended its usage for the wines made in Judea and Samaria by citing the free trade agreement between Canada and Israel.

That move was backed by Canada's attorney general, who said it was reasonable to refer back to the free trade agreement, given that the territory is "not part of a recognized country," and such a label would meet Canadian requirements.

But Judge Anne Mactavish said because "there is no dispute that the settlements in which the wines are produced are not part of the territory of the State of Israel," she was finding for Kattenburg.

"Identifying the wines as 'Products of Israel' is false, misleading and deceptive and interferes with the ability of Canadian consumers to make informed and rational decisions to buy conscientiously," she said.

"Individuals opposed to the creation of Israeli settlements in the West Bank need accurate information as to the origins of a product to be able to express their opposition," she added.

"Incorrectly identifying the wines as 'Products of Israel' inhibits the ability of consumers to express their political views through their purchasing choices" and limits their freedom of expression, she said.

Mactavish said the CFIA will have to determine how to label the wines.

In 2015, the European Union approved guidelines for member states to include the phrase "Israeli settlement" on labels of products from Jewish communities, in Judea and Samaria, eastern Jerusalem and the Golan Heights, all of which were captured by Israel in the 1967 Six-Day War.

Israel was furious at the move.




top