Hillel and American Jewish donors must reject Breaking The Silence

Hillel invites them to speak and prominent Reform leaders support NIF which funds them, although across the Israeli political spectrum they have been accused of harming Israel.

Ronn Torossian

OpEds Ronn Torossian
Ronn Torossian

Hillel International is the largest Jewish student group in the United States active on more than 550 college and university campuses in America.

In Hillel’s published Standards of Partnership, it pledges never to “partner with, house, or host organizations, groups, or speakers that as a matter of policy or practice- Deny the right of Israel to exist as a Jewish and democratic state with secure and recognized borders; Delegitimize, demonize or apply a double standard to Israel; Support boycott of, divestment from, or sanctions against the State of Israel; Exhibit a pattern of disrupting behavior towards campus events or guest speakers or foster an atmosphere of incivility.”

Against this backdrop, one wonders how leaders of Breaking the Silence (BTS) can be scheduled to speak at the Kraft Center Hillel House of Columbia University on March 31st

Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon accuses the extremist organization of committing “treason” over allegations that the group attempted to glean classified information from former Israel Defense Forces (IDF) soldiers: 

Israel’s Channel 2 (TV) reported last week that Breaking the Silence actively worked to place people in classified units in the IDF in order to gather information that it could use in its activities against “the occupation.” Additionally, activists from the group interviewed IDF veterans on issues related to military secrets, and not human rights.”

Just as a black church would not host the KKK, a Jewish organization designed to protect Jewish students should not host groups that are hostile to Israel.
This is not the first time that Hillel has engaged with Breaking the Silence; in 2013, the University of Pennsylvania Hillel offered BTS event space for a campus event.

Later that same year, with backing of the Harvard College Progressive Jewish Alliance, Friends of Breaking the Silence, the New Israel Fund, and J Street U Harvard - leaders of the group spoke at the Harvard Hillel.

Across the political spectrum, from Yesh Atid Chairman Yair Lapid to Labor Knesset members, Breaking the Silence has been accused of harming Israel.  Prime Minister Netanyahu has said that the organization crossed all red lines.  They are banned from Israeli schools and military bases – yet American Jewish student organizations honor them.

Hillel is meant to be a safe place for Jewish students, and just as a black church would not host the KKK, a Jewish organization designed to protect Jewish students should not host groups that are hostile to Israel.

Brian Cohen, executive director of the Columbia-Barnard Hillel, claims “[W]e must give our students the opportunity to listen and, if they desire, challenge the speakers’ ideas.”  He is wrong - Hillel must not allow that which Israel’s own Defense Minister Moshe Ya'alon deems unacceptable, to influence the minds of students, or to pose as an affront to students who support Israel. 

The activities of Breaking the Silence harm Israel – and lead to danger. 

Breaking the Silence is funded by the New Israel Fund and its donors, including Alisa Doctoroff of the UJA-Federation,  The Jewish Communal Fund, The Jim Joseph Foundation and Reform Rabbi Gordon Tucker of Temple Israel of White Plains.  These donors – as well as Hillel – must - stand with the Israel Defense Forces, and the State of Israel – and not those committing treason against the Jewish State.

Ronn Torossian is an entrepreneur and author.