"We feel like second-class citizens"

A new campaign by the Ne’emanei Torah v’Avodah raises awareness of couple who cannot marry in Israel and find a civil solution their problem

Arutz Sheva Staff,

Rabbi Aharon Katz
Rabbi Aharon Katz
Torah and Avodah Movement

A kohen and divorcee, a Jewess and a non-Jew, a convert and a kohen. These couples are the first voices in a new campaign by the Ne’emanei Torah v’Avodah campaign to raise awareness of couples who cannot marry in Israel, because their marriages are forbidden by the Torah, and there is no civil marriage in Israel.

The Ne’emanei Torah v’Avodah (literal meaning: Loyal to Torah and Labor), is a religious Zionist movement that claims it seeks to restore religious Zionism to its roots by integrating Torah with science, Zionism and modern life. It says that its purpose is to strengthen the integration of religious society into the general society in Israel to promote tolerance, equality and justice and to shape the Jewish-democratic character of Israeli society. The movement is seen as ultra-liberal Orthodox, says it is committed to Halakha-Jewish Law, to creating an open and critical religious culture and addressing the halakhic challenges of time.

In the campaign launched today, couples in Israel are calling for the State of Israel to find a solution for them and to allow a civil registration for these couples.

“The truth is that I never thought about it, because it seems natural that if a couple wants to, they marry. But when the moment came, we had to deal with it. I come from a home that had a lot of education in Judaism and tradition and we wanted to get married,” says Rinat Mezritz, a divorcee who lives in a relationship with Gilad Cohen. They have three children but are unable to register as a partner in Israel.

“You feel like a second-class citizen. It takes the wind out of the sails, and makes you a bit anti,” says Gilad, her partner.

“We knew that a problem may arise,” says Masha Friedman Cohen, the daughter of a Jewish father and a non-Jewish mother. She had undergone a complete Orthodox conversion as part of the Nativ program during her military service and encountered a problem getting marries when she met Ohad Cohen.

“But at the same time, we were 100% certain that it was just something that needed to find a simple solution to and will be resolved. Then in the end we would have to deal with the news that we simply could not get married here. We truly tried to do everything we can to keep the peace at home. We are talking of a traditional family. We did not plan to come head to head. At the end of the day, I felt that they were abandoning us.”

“I think that until something in this matter doesn’t get changed in the country, I and many others like me will feel that we are not the same as everyone. They know to recruit me, to take me to combat, but to marry, I can’t here,” says Galina Polishciuk, a daughter to a Jewish father and a mother who is not Jewish, lives in a relationship with Yonatan Maor.

“We give our share like any other citizen, but we have no solution,” says her partner Yonatan.

“There is a couple sitting here that just want to get married, and just want to find a solution to build a Jewish home. It should not be a nuisance, it does not need to be something that causes unpleasantness with our family. The time has come to find a solution,” Ohad Cohen says.

“I don’t feel like second-class,” says Rinat Mezritz. “I feel anger, antagonism, but I can understand where it all comes from. But I truly believe that there is a legitimate right that I deserve. Give an option, in a way that is possible [to marry].”

As part of the campaign, senior rabbis, who serve as marriage registrars in their cities, are being interviewed as well and are asked to find a solution to rectify the situation.

Rabbi Aharon Katz, acting rabbi and marriage registrar of the city of Ramat Gan explains that he has encountered the problems of marriage procedures many times in the framework of his job.

“There is a vital need for the couples. In my experience, there is no choice but to establish a broader marriage registration system recognized by the state that will give them [the couples] and their children all the rights. This way, every couple will be received in an equal manner, as is appropriate in a democratic country, the full rights to establish an orderly family, recognized with all rights.”

Rabbi Shmuel David, the rabbi of Afula, said, “It is unreasonable for these couples not to be recognized by the state. From a democratic perspective, it is impossible to prevent them from recognizing themselves as a couple. It is important to say that their registration by the state will definitely help Judaism.

Tani Frank, head of the Religious and State department of the Ne’emanei Torah v’Avodah movement, says, “The problem with the marriage procedures is a problem for all of us. We are talking of hundreds of thousands of citizens, most of whom immigrated to Israel under the Law of Return and of offspring of Israel and the state won’t allow them to institutionalize their relationship. This harms the existence of the state as a Jewish and democratic state. It is undemocratic and only brings about exclusion of many [men and women] from Judaism.”

The Ne’emanei Torah v’Avodah movement will soon present a position paper proposing solutions for regulating the status of couples in Israel.




top