Daily Israel Report
More

Zion's Corner Blogs


Holy Site Desecration Traced to Philistine Era

PA Arabs are not the first to desecrate holy sites. Archaeologists discover Philistines may have done the same 3,100 years ago.
By Tzvi Ben Gedalyahu
First Publish: 11/13/2012, 11:56 AM

Tel Beth Shemesh archaeological site
Tel Beth Shemesh archaeological site
Israel news photo courtesy of Tel Aviv Univ.

Tel Aviv University archaeology researchers have discovered unprecedented desecration of Israelite holy sites 3,100 years ago, possibly by Philistines, who the Palestinian Authority say are the original Palestinians.

The researchers uncovered a unique 11th-century BCE sacred compound at the site of Tel Beth-Shemesh, west of Jerusalem.

The newly discovered sacred complex at the site of an ancient village that resisted the aggressive expansion of neighboring Philistines is comprised of an elevated, massive circular stone structure and an intricately constructed building.

Co-directors of the dig, Tel Aviv Univ. Prof. Shlomo Bunimovitz and Dr. Tzvi Lederman, said that this temple complex is unparalleled, possibly connected to an early Israelite cult — and provides remarkable new evidence of the deliberate desecration of a sacred site.

It is not associated with the First Temple, which was built approximately a century later in Jerusalem. The Palestinian Authority has systematically removed tons of debris that includes artifacts from the First and Second Temples, and Muslims have been viewed desecrating the Temple Mount.

The desecration at the Tel Beht Shemesh was discovered through an analysis of weeds that showed that some animal pens had been placed at the temple site.

The village of Beth-Shemesh frequently changed hands between the ambitious Philistines and the Canaanite and Israelite populations that resisted them. The temple and its history reflect the power struggles that defined the region in the 12th-11th century BCE, say Prof. Bunimovitz and Dr. Lederman. Their findings will be presented this month at the annual meeting of the American Schools of Oriental Research in Chicago.

In the archaeological record, there are no parallels to this Canaanite or Israelite sacred compound of the period, note the researchers.

Excavators determined that the temple was not only destroyed, but also desecrated. More intensive scientific analysis of the site has shown that the temple ruins were used as animal pens, maybe by the invading Philistines.

After ruling out the use of the site as a domestic structure, the researchers knew that they had found something unique. Excavations revealed almost only shards of painted chalices and goblets found spread on the floor but no traces of domestic use.

One of the three flat stones was surrounded by animal bone remnants, and the two other stones were seemingly designed to direct liquids. These clues convinced Prof. Bunimovitz and Dr. Lederman that they had uncovered a likely place of sacred worship.

But the temple didn't remain sacred. Samples of earth taken from layers above the destroyed temple and analyzed at the Weizmann Institute of Science revealed astonishing results. Directly above the temple was a packed-in layer containing remains of weeds that are commonly eaten by livestock and microscopic remnants of manure produced by grass-eating animals, indicating the presence of animal pens directly on top of the sacred site, explains Prof. Bunimovitz.

Intermittent burning in order to clean the pens likely resulted in the concentrated state of the layer.

This desecration was no accident or coincidence, the researchers believe. Instead, it represents the see-saw of political might between the Philistines and the local population. Presumably the Philistines gained temporary control of Beth-Shemesh, and brought in livestock to live on what they knew had been a sacred site to their enemies.

This discovery also serves to illuminate the recent discovery of a number of round clay ovens, called "tabuns," in the layer excavated above the temple, according to Prof. Bunimovitz and Dr. Lederman.

Typically, such ovens were located in a domestic building for food preparation, explains Prof. Bunimovitz. But these particular ovens were not part of a neighborhood or living quarter. When the temple was discovered directly underneath, a plausible explanation for the mysterious ovens emerged.

"We believe that descendants of those who had built the original complex came back to rebuild the site," says Dr. Lederman, who suspects that the ovens were used to cook celebration feasts held in veneration of the old temple. Despite the desecration of the temple by the Philistines, the memory of the sacred site survived. Once the Philistines withdrew from the area, the descendents of the original worshippers returned to commemorate this sacred place.