David SingerDavid Singer is an Australian lawyer who is active in Zionist community organizations in that country. He founded the "Jordan is Palestine" Committee in 1979.
Any cynicism or disbelief that Israel's Prime Minister Netanyahu was seriously interested in trying to reach a two-state solution with the PLO was dispelled recently with the revelation that Netanyahu last year offered to free 50 long term Palestinian security prisoners sentenced before the Oslo Accords were signed in 1993 - in a vain bid to entice Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas back to the negotiating table.
Abbas's three year refusal to resume negotiations without a prior commitment from Netanyahu to freeze all building in East Jerusalem and the "West Bank" continues to cause US Secretary of State John Kerry growing frustration - after he had been investing considerable time and putting the prestige of his office on the line attempting to get Abbas to backdown.
Netanyahu has always made it clear that he will not commit to any such building freeze - for good reason.
A unilateral decison by Netanyahu to do exactly that for 10 months in November 2009 proved to be a farce. Abbas turned up shortly before the expiry date of the freeze and then had the temerity to request an extension.
Once bitten - twice shy.
In the bizarre bazaar that comprises these negotiations - refusing to agree to a building freeze as a condition for resuming talks apparently does not preclude Netanyahu offering an inducement to get Abbas back to the table by offering to release 50 long term prisoners with blood on their hands.
Israel previously offered to release several of the long term terrorist prisoners whose sentences preceded the Oslo Accords. Israel began by suggesting a small number of prisoners, but that number grew as time passed. Israel proposed freeing five prisoners after each meeting of Abbas and Netanyahu, up to a total of 25.
Abbas insisted on the freeing of all pre-Oslo terrorists from prison, before having a meeting with Netanyahu to inform him of the terms for talks. Freeing prisoners with blood on their hands was to be divorced from conditions for talks.
Once again Abbas apparently overreached and ended up a loser yet again - as has occurred on so many occasions with the Palestinian Arab leadership since the Mandate for Palestine was established by the League of Nations in 1922.
After this latest rebuff one can be excused for being slightly bemused when learning that Netanyahu told his cabinet that he and Secretary of State Kerry would "try to make progress to find the opening for negotiations with the Palestinians, with the goal of reaching an agreement”
However Netanyahu also made it clear that he would not deviate from the position he has consistently adopted since 2009:
"This agreement will be based on a demilitarized Palestinian state that recognizes the Jewish state, and on firm security arrangements based on the IDF (Israeli military)”
It must be crystal clear that the PLO can never agree to these conditions - which would undermine the PLO Charter claiming all of former Palestine to be an indivisible part of the Arab homeland.
So too - Israel can never accept the two-state solution propounded by the PLO - a Jew-free Arab state in all the territory lost by Jordan to Israel in the 1967 Six Day War - having its capital in Jerusalem - its current 500000 Jewish population having to abandon their homes - while millions of Palestinian Arabs are allowed to emigrate to Israel.
The two-state solution to be artificially created for the first time ever in history - as contemplated by the Oslo Accords and the Bush Roadmap - is dead in the water.
Is the international community so blind in failing to recognise the impossibility of creating a second Arab state in former Palestine - in addition to Jordan - given the totally divergent and unyielding positions that both Israel and the PLO hold?
How many more years must these "negotiations" continue before the penny drops?
More winks, nods, understandings and attempted back room deals leading nowhere seem to be the order of the day - whilst a vicious and unrelenting effort to undermine and delegitimise Israel continues with ever increasing ferocity and intensity.
Airlines, hotels and restaurants will be the only sure winners as the "negotiators" and their entourages flit from capital to capital in the never ending quest to never achieve their very different conceptions of the "two state solution".
Waiting in the wings is another " two-state solution" - based on history, geography and demography - that offers hope for the resolution of the long running Jewish-Arab conflict. It involves allocating sovereignty in the "West Bank" between Israel and Jordan - the two successor states to the Mandate for Palestine.
Not one Arab or Jew need move from his existing home under this scenario.
Jordan must first replace the PLO as Israel's negotiating partner before this solution can be addressed and progressed.
International diplomatic pressure coupled with financial, military and humanitarian aid to Jordan - rather than the PLO - would materially help in achieving this solution.
Meantime - the paradox of "negotiations with the PLO that are not negotiations" will continue going south until their inevitable denouement.
What cost to human suffering - both Jewish and Arab - will this pantomime continue to wreak until it finally becomes political history?