Straight Talk on Torah, Army and the Hareidim

There are good reasons for the issue coming to the fore now.

Contact Editor
Rabbi Eliezer Melamed,

מצווה. הרב מלמד
מצווה. הרב מלמד
פלאש 90

Political Issues

At the time the government coalition was being formed, I received a number of questions from the haredi public and their supporters, concerning the issue of army recruitment, and the alliance of the Bayit HaYehudi (Jewish Home) party with Yair Lapid's secular ‘Yesh Atid’ party and why the rabbis did not condemn it.

At the time, I avoided dealing with these issues, since all the rumors that were floated at the time were politically motivated, and it was difficult to separate the facts from the spins.

Additionally, dealing with these topics, which directly affected the political process going on at the time, was something into which I did not want to be drawn. Prior to elections, I do not express support for any specific party – even my family is unaware of whom I vote for. Political activity is indeed extremely important, and "'God bless all those involved in public affairs with integrity"(as it says in a blessing said in the Shabbat service), but in the framework of my duties, I am not required to engage in this demanding field. Furthermore, since many of the parties possess positive elements, I prefer to minimize my connection to one particular party.

Nevertheless, it seems that at the present, an attempt can be made to contend with the fundamental asoects of these important issues without a political context.

A Government without Haredim

At the time, I was asked: Why don’t you condemn the ‘Bayit HaYehudi’ party, which left the hareidim out of the government?

Answer: Beyond what I have already written concerning distancing myself from engaging in partisan political issues, I will add another point: People often come to me, asking that I use my authority as a rabbi to influence one of my students to listen to them – and I refuse. Only when both sides are ready to listen, am I willing to get involved. I am not willing to be manipulated in order to influence only one side.

The same holds true for political issues – the hareidi side sought to use the National Religious rabbis, without being prepared to hear their position on issues important to them, and in such a case, it is right not to get involved.

What's more, apparently the members of ‘Bayit HaYehudi’ acted correctly, claiming they originally sought to make an alliance with the hareidim, but the hareidim were not willing to commit to not entering the government without them. Nor were they willing to coordinate positions on issues that are important to the National Religious sector.  Afterwards, it became clear that Prime Minister Netanyahu had apparently asked the hareidi representatives not to do so, and they heeded his request.

Why Didn’t You Cooperate to Defend the ‘Torah World’?

Others asked: Why don’t you stand up for the hareidi yeshiva students, who are about to be forcibly recruited into the army?

Answer: A year ago, in a series of articles, I already warned the hareidi and religious communities that they must solve the question of recruitment. This was at the time that the Kadima party joined Netanyahu’s government, and the question of recruitment was at the top of the agenda.

It must be understood that the hareidi public’s participation in the burden of security is essential to Israel’s survival. First of all, the State of Israel, surrounded by numerous enemies, cannot rely solely on a professional army – it must possess a ‘people’s army’ founded on recruitment, supplementing our standing soldiers and preparing a large reserve force. Secondly, a situation where almost an entire population of Jews does not enlist in the army creates a catastrophic, national rift. It can clearly be seen how secular parties whose platforms explicitly called for the recruitment of hareidim into the army, grew from one election to the next (Tzomet headed by Rafael "Raful" Eitan, Shinui headed by Tommy Lapid, Yisrael Beyteinu headed by Avigdor Lieberman and Lapid's Yesh Atid).

Therefore, with all the admiration and deep connection I feel towards the hareidi community, the situation is hopeless. Perhaps the decisions can be delayed temporarily, but the national need and public pressure are mounting, and they must be dealt with straightforwardly.

The Problem Could Have Been Solved in the Previous Government

In the series of articles, I suggested increasing the numbers of hareidi youth enlisting in the army – at the very least, those who do not study Torah diligently. At the same time, I called attention to the secular nature of the army, which is the real obstacle facing the recruitment of hareidi and religious into the army.

In all my articles, I emphasized the significant importance of support for Torah students, for it is a top national necessity and ideal, ensuring the future existence of Israel for generations. Therefore, along with increasing the recruitment of hareidim who do not intend on becoming rabbis, the budget for those who study Torah diligently should be increased, such that the total budget invested in Torah study is not harmed.

I hoped that the representatives of the hareidi community would understand the situation, and offer a program of increasing participation of haredi youth in the IDF, thereby enhancing the Jewish character of the army, as well. In actuality, the opportunity to lead a gradual, positive process in the previous government was missed, and now, public pressure is palpable.

In any case, I was glad to read that the coalition agreement states that the budget for diligent Torah students will be increased threefold, exactly as I had written. It was also agreed that yeshiva students would not be forcibly recruited. Some hareidi functionaries – for reasons only they know – preferred to spread rumors about the decrees of shmad (forced conversion) and coercion, instead of taking action to modify the atmosphere in the army so as to be suitable for hareidi youth.

I still hope that the leaders of the hareidi community will join in the task of building an improved Jewish society in the State of Israel, and thereby increase Kiddush Hashem (sanctification of God) for the world's nations to witness.

Concerning the ‘Gedolim’ who Disgrace the Torah and Rabbis

Q: I read that a rabbi from the Eda Hareidit (hareidi community) said that the rabbis of the National-Religious community are “Reform” Jews and “uprooters of Torah”, and another said they are ‘amei ha’aretz’ (ignorant). How should we relate to those hareidi rabbis?

A: Concerning statements such as these, our Sages said: “He casts his own blemish on others” (Kiddushin 70a). And in this case, it is exactly right! After all, what is the person who said our rabbis are Reform, claiming? – That they invented "new" commandments, such as the mitzvah of yishuv ha’aretz (settling the Land), the mitzvah to protect the security of Israel, and the mitzvah to safeguard Israel’s unity.

Now, if he doesn’t know that there are entire passages written about this in the Torah, and that there is an entire book concerning this matter –the Book of Joshua – then he himself “uproots” and deletes parts of the Torah, and he himself could be labelled Reform!

Whoever claims that our rabbis are amei ha’aretz, is himself a complete am ha’aretz, believing he can twist all the verses and words of our Sages, according to his lack of understanding, and cancel the validity of commandments and laws.

And if he claims that involvement in the mitzvah of yishuv ha’aretz is liable to distance the youth from the Torah, this is exactly what the Reform claim, that strict observance of Shabbat distances Jews from keeping the tradition.

Furthermore, these individuals invent new prohibitions, thereby transgressing the prohibition of bal toseef (“You shall not add”). For example, the Torah did not prohibit studying the sciences and professions that people can make a respectful living from; nevertheless, they invented a new prohibition, according to which it is forbidden to learn sciences and professions, or at least not to teach it to the young.

True, there are rabbis in all religious sectors who believe initially it is better to teach children and teenagers only religious studies, and this is understandable. But anyone who claims that it is prohibited by the Torah, himself transgresses the prohibition of adding to the Torah, bal toseef.

Practically speaking, these Torah uprooters should not be considered talmidei chachamim (Torah scholars), and it is forbidden to honor them as rabbis –despite their misleading appearance. Unfortunately, “little foxes” in the form of mashgichim (supervisors), spokesmen, writers, and functionaries sanction their positions, creating a distorted impression in the hareidi media. But to my understanding, the vast majority of Torah scholars in the hareidi community are not mistaken on this issue, and all our disputes with them are over the details, so that it is a mitzvah to honor them as talmidei chachamim, to fear and love them.