International Conference of Chabad Women Emissaries
International Conference of Chabad Women Emissaries Jonathan Alpeyrie/Chabad.o

The Lubavicther Rebbe’s incisive analysis and approach towards security and sovereignty in the Jewish State are based on the Rebbe's reiteration of the principal Halakhic foundations for the State of Israel.

These are Shleimus Ha'aretz (territorial integrity) and Pikuach Nefesh (protecting Jewish lives). The Rebbe felt that Jewish Law requires a Jewish community to come together to form a framework to protect and save Jewish lives from danger; in the State of Israel, that community is its government.

Why did the Rebbe often use the expression Shleimus Ha'aretz, Shleimus Ha'am and Shleimus HaTorah (the integrity of the Jewish land, the People and the Torah) in that order? Wouldn’t it make sense to begin with the Jewish People and the Torah being united first and then focus together on making the Land of Israel intact?

The answer is an important one that reflects the entire hassidic weltanschauung going back to the holy Baal Shem Tov whose Ahavas Yisroel, love for his fellow Jews, was legendary.

At a time when the Jewish People were terribly downtrodden by the Chmielnicki pogroms, grinding poverty and the Shabbatai Tzvi debacle, the Baal Shem would first seek ways to relieve their physical plight and then closely follow by reviving their ailing spirit.

True peace, then, must begin, in our time, with Shleimus Ha'aretz – ensuring Jews are safe, secure and stable in Eretz Yisroel, the Land of Israel.

This has particular ramifications as Israel prepares to vote. Whoever leads the State of Israel and serves in the Knesset must be willing to publicly say this and demonstrate their commitment to Shleimus Ha'Aretz and Pikuach Nefesh. As the Rebbe said, “Giving away security and land is non-negotiable!"

This and related topics were addressed in an in-depth discussion at a recent Crown Heights Women for the Safety & Integrity of Israel event, second in its on-line series called Security and Sovereignty Over the Land of Israel. Rabbi Mendy Mirocznik, executive vice president of Igud HaRabbonim, the Rabbinical Alliance of America, led an in-depth discussion about the Halakhic (Jewish Law’s) priorities concerning security and sovereignty and how they reflect in the upcoming Israeli election which is scheduled for next week on March 23rd.

In addition to the above exposition of the Rebbe's views priorities of a Jewish State and the justification of its establishment, Rabbi Mirocznik was asked:

1/ What about the Joint Arab List, which is the third largest political faction in the Knesset, and which supports terrorism, Hamas and Hezbollah?

The Arab Joint List was appointed by Blue and White last year to the Knesset Welfare Committee which is tasked with overseeing services to wounded and disabled IDF and terror victims and also charged with confiscating PA Slay to Pay salaries to terrorists and their families.

Halakha’s answer is unequivocal: appointing the Arab Joint List to such a committee contravenes Jewish Law.

To quote Rabbi Mirocznik: "Empowering a fifth column that supports terrorism, Hamas, Hezbollah and BDS is no better than appointing a wolf to be the shepherd or the lion to be the zookeeper!” In his opinion, the silence and inaction by Knesset members to prevent their appointment is shameful and is a threat to all decent people in Israel whether Jewish, Muslim or Christian.

2. What about the ongoing saga of Malki Roth’s parents to bring to justice Ahlan Tamimi who masterminded the August 9, 2001 Sbarro pizza shop bombing in which Malki, HY”D, and 14 others died?

Tamimi was released in the Gilad Shalit swap in 2011 and repatriated to Jordan where she has since used every opportunity to incite further violence against Jews.

U.S. law provides for the extradition of terrorists who murder an American citizen on foreign soil to be brought to justice in the United States. Despite signing an extradition treaty with the U.S. in 1995, Jordan has refused to acknowledge it or turn Tamimi over.

Since Israel also signed an extensive peace treaty with Jordan in 1994, al pi Halakha – according to Jewish Law – may the State of Israel continue in its so-called friendly relationship with Jordan, and, thereby, let it get away with the argument? Press Jordan and any other country Israel has a treaty with on matters like these and the sky will fall! Rock the boat and peace might be lost at the border; the Oslo Accords, the Deal of the Century, The Abraham Accords, the Two-State Solution could easily disband and then what?!

Rabbi Mirocznik responded first by saying that American citizens should use every opportunity to press American public officials for Tamimi’s extradition. He pointed out that the Rebbe expressed concern about Israel taking foreign money and aid and that it was better for the State of Israel to rely on Hashem’s help and stand on its own two feet.

He quoted a beautiful medrash (commentary) from Shir Hashirim, the Song of Songs) about why the verses say that when the Jews crossed the Red Sea the waters surrounded them from the right and from the left rather than simply saying the waters surrounded them.

The answer is that the Torah is a best seller! When it comes to Pikuach Nefesh, ensuring safety, don’t look to the policies of the right or to the policies of the left, but rather look up Above to G-d Almighty for help. Policies can change, politicians and governments come and go, but the Torah will always remain the same.

Pikuach Nefesh is paramount and not something to play around with. A bad deal can and should be reevaluated and redone or dropped as needed to ensure that Jewish lives are protected, and justice is served.

3. With regard to Halakha’s position to the proposed revival of the ancient Silk Trade Route that would link the Gulf States to ports in Haifa and Ashdod by a central free trade zone in the Jordan Valley and to the efforts being made in creating functional peace in Judea and Samaria, Pikuach Nefesh must be the foundation these kinds of endeavors.

Tamar Adelstein heads CROWN HEIGHTS WOMEN FOR THE SAFETY AND INTEGRITY OF ISRAEL Uniting Jewish Women around the World under the Lubavitcher Rebbe’sDirectives for True Peace.