Pesach is what holiday are we still celebrating?

The Korban Pesach was offered on the 14th of Nisan, but matzot were the food that we ate for a month after leaving Egypt – and they had the taste of manna, no less.

Daniel Pinner

Judaism Matzah

Yes, you read the title correctly. The Pesach holy day has indeed ended.

“But wait” – I already hear you protest – “it’s still Pesach. It’s now Chol ha-Mo’ed, the Intermediate Days of Pesach! How can you say that Pesach has ended?!”

So let’s throw out a couple of simple questions:

  • When exactly is Pesach?
  • And what is the first festival after Pesach?

The answers that almost every Jew will give are:

Pesach lasts for seven days, from the 15th to the 21st of Nissan (or eight days, to the 22nd of Nissan, outside of Israel). And the first festival after Pesach is Shavuot.

Sorry, wrong answers.

The Torah commands us to celebrate Pesach:

“These are Hashem’s appointed festivals…: In the first month [Nissan], on the fourteenth of the month in the afternoon is Pesach for Hashem. And on the fifteenth day of this month is the Festival of Matzot for Hashem; for seven days you shall eat matzot” (Leviticus 23:4-6).

Pesach lasts only half-a-day: it begins in the afternoon of the fourteenth of Nissan, the day on which we are commanded to offer the Pesach-sacrifice, and concludes at midnight of the Seder Night, the latest time for eating the Pesach-sacrifice. And the first festival after Pesach is Chag ha-Matzot, the Festival of Matzot, which lasts for seven days, from the fifteenth to the twenty-first of Nissan (or the twenty-second outside of Israel).

True, it is popularly called Pesach (or Passover), but this is an inaccurate colloquialism. In the prayers, it is always called Chag ha-Matzot – which is its rightful name.

The Seder Night is a brief overlap of Pesach and Chag ha-Matzot, both Festivals simultaneously. But at midnight the time for eating the Korban Pesach expires, and Pesach is over. From then on for seven days we celebrate Chag ha-Matzot.

The Torah gives the reason for the Festival of Matzot:

“This day will be your day of remembrance, and you will celebrate it as a festival to Hashem for all your generations; as an eternal decree shall you celebrate it. For seven days you will eat matzot…. So you will safeguard the matzot, because on this very day I have taken your legions out of the land of Egypt, so you will safeguard this day throughout your generations as an eternal decree” (Exodus 12:14-17).

We all know the story perfectly well: “They baked the dough that they had brought out of Egypt into cakes of matzot because it had not leavened, because they had been driven out from Egypt, and they could not wait; neither had they brought any provisions with them” (v. 39).

Thirty days later, “on the fifteenth day of the second month” (Exodus 16:1), the Children of Israel faced starvation in the desert:

“The entire congregation of the Children of Israel complained against Moshe and Aaron in the wilderness. The Children of Israel said to them: If only we had died at Hashem’s hand in the land of Egypt, while we were dwelling by the flesh-pots, when we were eating bread to satiety! But you have brought us out to this wilderness to put this entire assembly to death by starvation” (vs. 2-3).

The implication is that the matzot which they brought from Egypt lasted for thirty days, from the 15th of Nisan to the 15th of Iyar.

G-d responded to these justified complaints: “Hashem said to Moshe: Behold! I am about to rain food from heaven down on you” (Exodus 16:4).

This food from heaven was what the Israelites called Mann (Manna): “When the layer of dew rose, behold! – there was something thin and wafery on the surface of the wilderness, thin as the frost on the ground. And the Children of Israel saw, and they said to one another מָן הוּא [mann hu], because they did not know what it was” (verses 14-15).

The phrase מָן הוּא is variously understood to mean “This is preparation for food” (Rashi ad loc., Metzudat Zion to Psalms 68:24); or “What is this?” (Rashbam); or “It is food” (Ibn Ezra); or “It is a gift” (Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch). 

In any event, “the House of Israel called it mann” (Exodus 16:31); “and the Children of Israel ate the mann for forty years, until their arrival in a settled land; they ate the man until their arrival at the edge of the Land of Canaan” (verse 35).

The Talmud (Kiddushin 38a) sees a difficulty in this verse: “Did they really eat it for forty full years? Actually they ate it for forty years less thirty days!”

The calculation is simple (see Rashi on Exodus 16:35): the mann began falling for the Children of Israel on the 16th of Iyyar. Forty years later, they entered the Land of Israel on the 10th of Nissan (Joshua 4:19); then “the Children of Israel encamped in Gilgal, and they carried out the Pesach-sacrifice on the fourteenth day of the month…and the mann desisted the next day, when they ate of the grain of the Land; there was no more mann for the Children of Israel, and they ate of the produce of the Land of Canaan in that year” (Joshua 5:10-12).

Hence the mann stopped falling on the 16th of Nissan – forty years less thirty days after it began. 

The Talmud (ibid.) resolves this apparent contradiction: “This tells you that the taste of the cakes which they had brought out of Egypt was the taste of man”.

This makes the mitzvah of eating matzot on Chag ha-Matzot far more powerful than merely eating crackers for a week. The matzot were the food that we ate for a month after leaving Egypt – and they had the taste of manna, no less.

Chag ha-Matzot, the Festival of Matzot, is our annual celebration of eating the original matzot that we had baked while still in Egypt – and which had the taste of the manna with which G-d would feed us for almost forty years in the desert while travelling to Israel.

And the manna itself, holy and spiritual though it certainly was, was but a substitute for the produce of the Land of Israel. And the produce of the Land of Israel, the truly holy and spiritual food, is what we begin to celebrate on the second day of Chag ha-Matzot, when we begin to count the Omer – the beginning of the harvest in the Land of Israel. 

What a truly awe-inspiring thought to chew over while chewing the matzot, now that Pesach is over and we are celebrating Chag ha-Matzot!