Shlach (Israel): Understanding the sin of the spies

This week's Dvar Torah is by Rabbi Ronen Neuwirth, former Central Shaliach of Bnei Akiva North America, currently Rabbi of Kehillat Ohel Ari in Raanana and member of Beit Hillel. The reading is Israel's, the message for the Diaspora.

Torah Mitzion Torani Tzioni Movement

Judaism Torah Mitzion
Torah Mitzion

The main theme of our Parsha is obviously the sin of the Meraglim (spies). Nevertheless, there are a few other Mitzvot that we encounter in our Parsha, which are seemingly not related to this event. The Parsha brings up certain commandments such as the Nesachim (Drink-offerings), Hafrashat Chalah and Tzitzit , Mitzvot which might have been placed in a better place like Sefer Vayikra for instance, a book which deals with Korbanot (offerings) and Kodshim (sanctity).

To understand this, we must understand the puzzling sin of the Meraglim. The Meraglim were surely “The heads of Bnei Yisra’el”, as the Torah says. The people listed here are those distinguished from the rest of the nation, because of their special status and standing in Torah – two of the most famous among them serving as examples for this fact: Kalev ben Y’funeh, and Yehoshua bin Nun. It is a collection of great individuals, who we would describe as “G’dolei ha’Dor – The Giants of the Generation.”

How did it happen that those Gedolim made this huge error? Why didn’t those spiritual leaders want to enter Eretz Yisrael? After witnessing all of the miraculous redemption from Egypt, after Pharaoh, “the king of the world”, was defeated, the least that one would expect of those leaders would be for them to believe in the power of Hashem and to trust Him to fulfill His promise of Eretz Yisrael!? 

The Sfat Emet (Admor of Gur) had a tremendous insight on this matter. He points out on the commentary of the Zohar, as follows:

“The Zohar states that the spies thought: ‘Here, (in the desert,) we are the leaders (of Bnei Yisrael) in the Land (of Israel) we will not merit to be the leaders.’”. According to the Zohar, they were concerned about losing their spiritual influence by entering Eretz Yisrael, and therefore decided that for the sake of the Torah, it is better to dwell in the Galut. But that is not the root of the problem, it is just the symptom. This would seem to explain that, indeed, the generation of the desert, in general, were identified through the aspect of the ‘Head.’ For the generation which left Egypt, and heard the (Ten) Commandments at Sinai, was the ‘Head’ of all the other generations. The generations then continue as ‘Avot’ (‘Archetypes’) and ‘Toladot’ (‘Derivatives’) from the ‘Heads’ to the ‘Feet,’ as it is stated about our generations (being) ‘Ikvata d’Mashicha’ – ‘the heels of Mashi’ach.’. And this was certainly true, for the entry in the Land of Eretz Yisrael was a level subsequent to that level, and they did not want to descend from the level of ‘Heads.’” (Sfat Emet Ibid.)

The spies were indeed Gedolim. They had very good intentions. They were very comfortable with the spiritual life in the desert. Having heavenly bread – manna, each and every day, revealing the Shechina clearly, following the fire and the cloud pillars, those are benefits, which are not easy to give up. The spies were sure that for Am Yisrael, which was totally immersed in a spiritual environment at the time, entering Eretz Yisrael would be a disaster.  

Surely, they believed that they would defeat the enemies in Eretz Yisrael with the help of Hashem, but for that there is a need to establish an army. Also, there is a necessity to establish political and economical systems, as well as expectations to settle Eretz Yisrael - the land that is flowing milk and honey. If Am Yisrael will have to deal with all those tasks- who will sit and study Torah? We will lose our spiritual level!!! Therefore, the spies decided to do Hashem a “favor” – let’s stay here in the Diaspora, the Galut, where we can serve you much better than from Eretz Yisrael - it is for the sake of the Torah!!!  

The root of this sin was the lack of ability to integrate heaven and earth. The Torah of Eretz Yisrael is the Torah that provides us with the skills to spiritually uplift matters which are mundane. In Eretz Yisrael the Avoda (labor) is integral part of Torah fulfillment. The letter and the spirit of the Torah cannot be achieved at its optimal level without the Avoda component. Hashem prefers for us to elevate the bread that comes from the ground – המוציא לחם מן הארץ – to our eating heavenly bread – the manna. 

Thus it was so important to receive the new Mitzvot right after the sin. Hashem wanted to comfort Bnei Yisrael for losing the heavenly virtues, and therefore provided them with substitutes. The Hafrashat Chalah enables as to take earthly bread and transform it into a heavenly one. The Nesachim are the substitute for the heavenly well, and the Tzitzit is the compensation for the heavenly clouds of glory (ענני הכבוד). The ultimate way of Avodat Hashem is indeed to live in a heavenly manner but while been grounded and attached to earth – by the virtue of Eretz Yisrael, the land of Torah V’Avodah. 

Torah MiTzion was established with the goal of strengthening Jewish communities around the globe and infusing them with the love for Torah, the Jewish People and the State of Israel. Over the past twenty years Torah MiTzion has recruited, trained and dispatched more than eleven hundred ‘shlichim’ to Jewish communities in countries spanning five continents.  These shlichim have inspired and enriched their host communities through a wide range of formal and informal educational programs.