sRepliesHTML = "";iReplies = 24;mReplies = iReplies;iDiv = 3041
AddReply(349457,"For the violent vel.","Richard","Chicago","10/06/08","\" What is a \"Jewish reaction\" ? You mean the Jewish reaction to the truth like when we EMBRACE the truth and reject your man-god-idol?\"\n\nYour the fine example.\nYour calling ME names and totally upset that I brought out an issue that has been buried.  \nON PURPOSE and NOT because of the Police not finding the culprits.  Go ask them YOURSELF.\nI have talked with whom we shall just call officials. unofficially. off the \'record\' and totally denied.\n\nI NEVER said anything to allow you to call me a missionary or a worshiper of a man-god.  YOU call me a rat and I cannot be antisemetic as I am a Jew living in Israel, and yes I go back to Chicago frequently.\nThat is YOUR Lashon Hora against me.\nTough nuggies");
AddReply(348939,"Now I know...Mike Tzadak (is right) Pt 2 of 2","Anon Now","Anon Now","10/05/08","cont......\n\nThis scenario is hauntingly familiar to another tragic event in Jewish History.\nLet us examine the story of Masada.\n\nhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masada\n\nAfter reading the story of Masada, consider the following: How come the Masadians didn\'t kill the Romans as they built up to conquer Masada?  The answer is because the ascending infrastructure was being built by Jewish slaves, who were captured by the Romans during the horrific Jerusalem slaughter just years before.\nBecause they refused to stop the captured Jewish slaves, they ultimately committed suicide.\n\n\n\nIt is a tragedy of utmost proportions that this Yeshiva Scholar/Soldier is facilitating the IDF\'s continued cruel and oppressive occupation of Yitzhar and other Yesha communities.  But if the residents of Yitzhar will forego self-defense because of him, they are choosing suicide.\n\nMike is right this time.\n");
AddReply(348933,"Now I know...Mike Tzadak (is right) Pt 1 of 2","Anon now","Anon now","10/05/08","For a long time, I have had trouble understanding Mike\'s formulation of Living in Israel as \"suicide because the Jews refuse to take any action to defend themselves.\"  I always thought of suicide as an active, rather passive attempt on one\'s own life.\n\nNow I understand.  See Dr. KIein\'s comments above towards the end.  He writes as follows \n- \"Though I understand the frustration of the Jews of Yitzhar, I unreservedly disapprove of their throwing stones at IDF soldiers in Yosh.  One of those stoned was a grandson of Rav Kapach, ZT”L, and a former student at the yeshiva in Maale Adumim\".\nSo the sitiuation as I understand it is as follows:  The Jews of Yitzhar should not defend themselves against the IDF because there are rightous individuals amoungst the soldiers, and we can\'t hurt them since they are our brothers..... (cont...)");
AddReply(348364,"To Dickie 15 the antisemitic vermin","Velvel","silver spring","10/03/08","Once again Dickie chimes in with more blood libels against the Jewish people.    \"Jewish reaction to the truth\"   What kind of sick piece  of  garbage are you?   What is a \"Jewish reaction\" ?    You mean the Jewish reaction to the truth like when we EMBRACE the truth and reject your man-god-idol?    If A7 publishes your sick antisemitic comments and blocks this response, this website is insane.  \n\nYou are utter drek and don\'t belong here.   This is a Jewish site.  If you are in need of rehabilitation, try JewsforJudaism.org      ");
AddReply(348362,"Gary - \"force\" me?   ","Velvel","silver spring","10/03/08","I\'m sure you\'d butcher the rat in inhumane fashion in direct violation of noahide laws that are binding on ALL Jews and Gentiles.  In response, I\'d slaughter you before you could get the rat off the stove...  Your missionary friend would make good company with you too.   Or was that the \"rat\" you referred to?");
AddReply(348301,"#10 Velvel - If you were my student,","Gary","Monterey, CA","10/02/08","I\'d wash your mouth with soap and then force you to eat a cooked rat!");
AddReply(348247,"# 15, Hey Richard","Rob","usa","10/02/08","It would not suprise me if sternhell blew himself up. he is sick. or maybe some of his sick followers, but most likely it was sabak trying to smear the right in the usual fashion.\n \n");
AddReply(347644,"Dear Dr. Klein","Rob","usa","09/29/08","You are suggesting time will solve this problem. I think sixty years is ample time. there are aprox. four hundred thousand religious Jews in Israel, out of what? five million. Even if we give you another half million who are sympathetic to the faithful, this still leaves you  outnumbered . To sit, wait and hope does not look like a viable option.");
AddReply(347537,"Well","Larry","TA","09/28/08","First, Dr. Klein needs evidence that a right-winger did this. He is condemning \'wicked fools\', which sounds like a knee-jerk reaction to the incident and the gov\'t pressure that he knew would follow. Today, Oilymert did not disappoint, though he\'s effectively no longer PM. Or should not be. \n\nI am against violence of this sort, so whoever did it should be punished, including if that \'who\' is a government agent(s). We don\'t know, and of course the mainstream media will \'convict\' the entire nationalist opposition rather than launch an objective inquiry.\n\nAt the same time, reading this made me think of other pieces where the writer said the next generation would be the ones to face down a gov\'t which is also a semi-police state. It sounds like Dr. Klein is saying in so many words, \'I won\'t take militant actions but it\'s okay if my kids do.\' Which sounds like \'someday we\'ll have to but I can\'t.\' \n\nIf that analysis is correct, then he should just say he\'s not willing to physically resist the next Gush Katif. It seems to me that if lawful communities in Judea/Samaria are targeted for \'disengagements\' than such resistance is legitimate. Though I am far closer to Klein\'s age than to his kids, I would most likely participate. \n\nOf course, reading about the Sternhell episode and what Olmert and Livni are doing with it makes me wonder if there really is hope for Israel in the long run.");
AddReply(347419,"I must have it right.","Richard","Chicago","09/28/08","Velvel is incensed he/she is spitting.\nI talked with a few locals and their reaction is the police KNOW who did it and are afraid of EXACTLY vels tye of jewish reaction to the truth.\nTough Nuggies.\n\nMike: acknowledged.");
AddReply(347397,"Obeying Laws Of The State Is NOT A Suicide Pact","Adina Kutnicki","Israel,new olah","09/28/08","IF heaven forbid the State sanctions orders to shoot/kill those being expelled from their homes for refusing their dictates, then it is incumbent upon said individuals to protect themselves.\n\nThere is NO law-Israeli or international-which does not sanction self defense. Just because a State-Jewish or otherwise-gives an order, does NOT make it de facto legal.Some orders are inherently illegal AND immoral.\n\nFurther, once the Israeli leadership turns its own forces(like Golems) against its majority citizens (its Jews) it is no longer legitimate.\n\n");
AddReply(347280,"Let\'s figure this one out","Logic-man","Planet earth, Israel","09/27/08","Man X proposes to defeat and overturn the evil forces of side A by arrangements of side B - man X\'s affiliation.\n\nSide A uses violence and brute force against side B.  Side A will stop at nothing to destroy side B and no act no matter how vicious is ever crossing a red line of any kind.  Side A has already thrown thousands from Side B out of their homes by force.\n\nMan X says Side B must win and overcome Side A but not use any tactics that are considered distasteful or violent in any way.   Even tho Side A is permitted to use these tactics against Side B - and is not criticized, nor stopped by anyone.\n\nEasy Equation.  Side A wins every time.   Side B hopes for miracles.   And loses.");
AddReply(347201,"violent jews?","ruth","jerusalem","09/27/08","how can you condemn the wicked fools who planted the pipe bomb?\ndo you know who they are?\nwhere they jews?\narabs have been used many times to do the dirty work of our leaders\nleft wing is capable of anything\nto vilify and demonise religous jews\nwake up - you condemn because you are singing from the same song sheet as all the rest - \ni thought you were supposed to be telling the truth\nwhy did it take you so long to at long long long last deceide to speak out\nyou knew about it for many years\nare you media people who claim to be religious - so desperate to be part of the only game in town that you comprimise\nare you cowards?\nis the price to heavy to pay to speak out - jail, loss of job etc?\n\nmy great  great grandfather was a famous rabbi - he was called after his personality - he was sharp, sarcastic, straight and humble and he hated hated hateld llies\nhis name is rabbi aisel harif\nwhen i started to become religious here in jerusalem 6 years ago.\ni was looking for another rabbi harif.\nthere are none\nafter rabbi  khanane  there is no one\nrabbi harif did not do talking\nhe did actions\nhe fought to stop the jewish boys being forced into the polish army\nif he was alive today he would close down all the brothels\n(including the knesset and some bet knessets as well)\nhe would be fighting for torah\nhe is not here - i am\nseeing as not a single man seems to be up to the job of doing something to save the jewish nation\nyou are all busy with empty words\nempty words do not give a house or job or food to the poor\nthe holocaust survivor\nthe gush katif people\nthe drug addict\nthe trouble soul\nwhich our school system works hard to produce\n STOP ALL THE DAMN WORDS\nrav harif once asked a student - (obvously a self righteous idiot)\n\"what would you do if someone is bleeding\" answer \" i will check the books\"  - \" close the  books - go and save the man\" ordered the rav");
AddReply(347073,"To #9:  I approve of following Hashem\'s Torah","Mike","Vienna, VA","09/26/08","Hashem has clearly stated what is to be done to those who entice Jews to worship alien gods.");
AddReply(347011,"To Dickie #9, the antisemitic vermin","Velvel","silver spring","09/26/08","Hey Dickie, guess what, there\'s no evidence that a Jew did that.  So why do you assume and insist it was a Jew?   In fact, an Arab has bombed that family before.   Save your blood libels you missionary piece of garbage.   Why don\'t you summon that family to leave Israel and come live with you in Chicago if you\'re so worried about their safety you rat.");
AddReply(346948,"What do you think?","Richard","Chicago","09/26/08","\"Therefore I think it is incumbent on us never to use violence against another Jew in a political context, even in self-defense. \"\n\nDo YOU aprove of the jewish bombing of a young man in Ariel?");
AddReply(346782,"I was going to write a more lengthy response...","Mike","Vienna, VA","09/25/08","...to Klein\'s drivel when I realised that there is no need.  I have already written three.\n\nhttp://virtualjudah.wordpress.com/whose-idea-was-it-anyway/\n\nhttp://virtualjudah.wordpress.com/2008/07/27/abkhazia-a-cautionary-tale/\n\nhttp://virtualjudah.wordpress.com/2008/07/31/artsakh-an-example-to-emulate/\n\nThere is no point in repeating myself.\n");
AddReply(346754,"Fortunately, the young MEN of Yesha...","Mike","Vienna, VA","09/25/08","...disagree with the prattling of this self-castrating lemming.  \"Therefore I think it is incumbent on us never to use violence against another Jew in a political context, even in self-defense.\" -- therefore you are dead meat.\n\nMake no mistake about it, civil war is to be avoided at all costs.  But a doctrinally correct armed struggle to liberate Medinat Yehudah from Israeli occupation is the only hope of Jewish survival.  The young men of Yesha know this instinctively.  May Hashem guide their blows, both against the Israeli enemy and the self-castrating lemming voices of suicide and surrender.\n\nP.S. Those who lack the education to understand the difference between civil war and armed struggle for national liberation are advised to become educated.");
AddReply(346710,"While waiting for Vienna Mike ...","sk","USA","09/25/08","... some comments.  First, I\'m inclined to side with Wilder\'s take on this.\n\nSecond, is the real issue Jewish violence against Jews or Jewish violence against ISRAELIS?\n\nThird, since when is nonviolence Jewish? I mean, I wear no kippah, but by now I know something about Halacha just from hanging around here, and Klein even references Chazal, who seems to oppose ... Klein!\n\nFourth, why conflate the use of violent means with civil war?  This is a leftist trick from way back, and the so-called Right has always played into it.  E.g., when Ben-Gurion and Peres tried to murder Begin and then \"fretted\" publicly, along with Begin, about civil war.  Civil war is two-way street, and it can be avoided by eiher or both parties.  May I suggest that we view the situation in Israel as a war that is to be avoided by making escalation dangerous to the Left?  As a scientific matter, \"tit for tat\" is a robust approach.\n\nFifth, agitating for Medinat Yehudah is an alternative to civil war, as it does NOT involve fighting to gain control over Israel, but over Judeah.\n\nSixth, if Dr. Klein is going to write a piece like this, does he also oppose nonviolent direct action?  If so, does he have evidence that elections or public yakking will fix this decades-old problem?  If not, why not advocate this alternative approach?  I\'m still waiting for ACT UP/Settlers to have its first meeting.\n\nSeventh, everything that I have said here should have been obvious to Dr. Klein.  But when smart people do not write smart pieces--especially when their own Jewish values would lead them to--I immediately suspect unthinking, conditioned responses being the root cause.");
AddReply(346680,"Condemning the pipebomb at Sternheller\'s","CDG","Yerushalayim","09/25/08","Shana Tovah, kativa tovah v\'chatima tovah. I just heard about this through the A-7 blogs. \n\nAs long as you don\'t presume whom it might be, I am with you in condemning the perpetrator. Violence against fellow Jews doesn\'t help, but neither does jumping to conclusions as to who commit it. Only haShem and the perp know at this point - though your fellow blogger David Wilder has some thoughts.");
AddReply(346667,"Ps. Dr. Klein","Rob","usa","09/25/08","You\'ve rasied some awesome Kids, pat yourself on the back");
AddReply(346666,"The blame for Israel\'s woes...","Observant observer","","09/25/08","has been leveled at every place possible, but the true heart of her problems lies not with her average citizens, but with Israel\'s leaders.\n\nIsrael\'s citizens, same as US citizens, have simply been trying to raise their families and be a benefit to, and benefit from, just being residents.\n\nQuite honestly, that is all that should be expected from anyone.\n\nHowever, the evil ones in power know this, and used the preoccupation of good citizens to rob them, bit by bit, of what they hold dear.\n\nThose who reject the obvious trends of conspiracy are either globalist \"plants\" or ignorant. Both are undesirable. Both shall in time suffer the consequences of wrong decisions.\n\nCivil war in Israel is a preplanned tactic, its goal is to divide and conquer. Only the globalist will emerge the true winner, in the short run. \n\nAnyone can shout fight, fight, fight, but does anyone see those who shout it the loudest fighting? No? Why not?\n\nThe answer lies in the fact that those who promote violence know in their hearts that they cannot \"win\" either. Why is that?\n\nThe answer lies in the fact that \"SAMPSON  IS BOUND\"! Could Sampson \"fight\" he would do so. It is that simple. What then lies in store for Israel in this impossible situation?\n\nAnswer: according to the TANAKH, war is inevitable. Not just Israel will be involved, but the whole planet.\n\nNow is the time for parents to look after the welfare of their children. Now is the time for children to look after their parents. Now is the time for all of us to repent, look to Hashem, and prepare for the worst while hopeing for the best.\n\nNow is the time to study the TANAKH for only it has the clues and answers for our survival.\n\nThe good news is, HaShem will save those who are righteous for Himself, whether it be in this life, or the one to come. The good news is: among the righteous WILL BE SURVIVORS!\n\nNo one else has that promise. The TANAkh says, \"even the mightiest soldier will flee away naked on that day\" (Amos). \"And they who are wise will shine like the brightness of heaven; and those who turn many to righteousness - as the stars for ever and ever.\"\n\nThere is great hope for the future even as the day darkens.  Moms, their is still hope and reason to be encouraged for your children - even tho the bodies of the dead pile high.\n\nNo one has the hope and promises of the Jew, except the Jew and those who align with us. For  them, we are still the light of the world, and the only hope they will ever know.\n\nWar is inevitable... but  so is LIFE!\n");
AddReply(346665,"I find it ineteresting that......","Rob","usa","09/25/08","Teen aged girls get it. Thank HaShem for teen age girls!");
AddReply(346652,"Internacine violence","Irwin Ruff","US","09/25/08","I agree with you completely that civil war is likely to spell the end of Israel. But neither can we expect the right to act like complete pacifists and not fight back against agression. When there is an attack by Arabs, and the IDF stands by and watches, and intervenes only if the Jews attempt to defend themselves and their fields, this is already setting the stage for civil war. When further none of the Arab aggressors is even detained for questioning, but the Jews are arrested, we are already seeing a major split in the country. When the lies of Arabs, egged on by their left-wing inciters, are automatically believed, while statement of Jews are ignored, we have already reached the situation of two antagonistic parties. Add to this the various forms of preventative detention for members of the right only, while Arab and leftist rioters are unmolested, we already have a split between the government and a nationalist group of Jews that brings back unpleasant memories. What the actions of the government remind me of are the actions of the British pre 1948. The government will have to modify its unthinking leftist position. If not, while we are not yet to the formation of groups like Etzel and Lehi, we will soon see it. ");

WriteReplies(6,3041,iDiv);