sRepliesHTML = "";iReplies = 26;mReplies = iReplies;iDiv = 8779
AddReply(439734,"Robinson, et al","Samuel L. Frydman","Ft. Lauderdale","05/21/09","We are all entitled to our own opinions in USA. Mine is that those who wish to appear &/or identify as swine, should be left to define themselves. \n\n");
AddReply(439148,"Uncomfortable Parallels","Andrew","USA","05/20/09","Germans built wall and fence around the Warsaw ghetto, trapping Jews.  Jews entered and exited when and where Germans permitted it.  Germans controlled supply streams.  Guard towers and checkpoints kept track of what were effectively prisoners.  Poverty and disease spread all around.  When Jews resisted their treatment, the Germans entered the ghetto and massacred them, destroying their homes and businesses.  Prior to ghettoization there was forced relocation, ethnic cleansing in preparation for new settlements.  I don\'t have enough characters to continue.  You know the score. Don\'t be thick.\n\nThere\'s are no gas chambers in Palestine. Historical analogies need not be exact in every detail. The point of historical comparison is to demonstrate the resort to similar tactics and the common sociological forces underpinning oppressive projects--to reveal uncomfortable parallels. ");
AddReply(437552,"He even likes a non Jewish Surname-was it Rabinowitz before?","Alan ","SA","05/16/09","");
AddReply(437514,"Why fault Robinson?","Israel Tal","Lompoc, CA","05/16/09","Yeah, Robinson is a self-hating Jew.  But are his actions any worse than that of the Santa Barbara Jewish Federation and UCSB Hillel who continue to bring an unending stream of Israeli leftists to this very campus?");
AddReply(437511,"Andrew you\'re not too bright","NoBS","Chicago","05/16/09","Just because a so-called professor makes an historical analogy does not make it valid.  You also conveniently dodge the dismantling of your willfully ignorant postings by other commenters.");
AddReply(437483,"israel bashing","cal","ellicott city","05/16/09","As Solomon said, \'there is nothing new under the sun.\'\nPart of fallen man\'s DNA is Israel hatred. Hatred of the Israel of God is really hatred of the God of Israel.\nFallen man cannot get his hands on the God of Isael - from whom He is desperately fleeing - but He can get his hands on the Israel of God. Take heart my Jewish friends - in the end you will be thoroughly vindicated as the elect of God - the apple of his eye - and the one about whom God said, \'of all the nations of the earth, you and you along have I known.\'");
AddReply(437465,"Andrew","Yehoshua Gavriel","Tel Tzion","05/16/09","Tell me Andrew, where are the GAS CHAMBERS???  Mass graves???  Human transports???  Gas Chambers???  How many Arabs have been \"murdered\"???  The fact is that Robinson and those like him, such as yourself, are Jew haters!  You can attempt to hide behind your false reality but facts are facts PERIOD!  THERE ARE NO SIMILARITIES BETWEEN WHAT HAPPENED IN WWII to our containment and separation of people who are constantly attempting to murder us...  Of course, you\'re probably a fan of late term and partial birth abortion too so killing is really relative right?  I mean it\'s alright to kill a Jew or two, and babies of course, but arab murderers must be left alone.  Your argument belies your twisted ideology and that is why the world, sans world despots, has disavowed you and your kind.  Why dont you hang up pictures of dead Jews and dead babies in your home, Im sure these images please you... ");
AddReply(437419,"Are We Good Germans?","Andrew","USA","05/15/09","So, Big Eye, you are telling us that the problem with Robinson, Farve, and myself is that we are not good Germans.\n\nGot it, Big Eye.  Dissent is betrayal.  Dissent is bigotry.  I am receiving your message loud and clear.");
AddReply(437406,"Ticker Misunderstands the Point of Education","Andrew","USA","05/15/09","Ticker, \n\nThe students are entitled to their opinions, too.  But instead of giving their opinion in the classroom where the debate was held, they dropped the class and complained to outside parties who are now smearing Robinson. It was a cowardly act that undermines their purpose in being there: to learn to think critically about historical events.\n\nIn a class on global issues, it is the responsibility of the teacher to present global issues and interpretations of them. The invasion of Gaza is a global issue. History imposed the event on the classroom. Robinson simply brought the event and arguments into the classroom so that his students could debate them. That\'s his job as a sociology teacher. \n\nYou don\'t create a hostile environment by debating hostile events around the world in a sociology course on global events. \n\nYou don\'t seem to get the point of a university education.");
AddReply(437361,"To Andrew","Big Eye","Almost No Where","05/15/09","Please allow me to bother you with just a few more of my inane comparisons.\nSome people ask how the US would deal with Mexico or Canada putting up with being rocketed.  But let\'s put it into better perspective.  Let\'s say that Mexico and Canada are the enemies of your lovely state of Wsconsin.  However so are all the rest of the states as well as Central and South America.  the rockets come from avid enimies Michigan and Minnesota as well as Illinois and parts of your own population all hoping to push those called \"Badgers\" into Lake Michigan.\nPeople try to come over your border to bomb buses on Wisconsin Ave in Milwaukee, blow up Lambeau Field and attack Capitol Square in Madison.  Some from your state are financed by other states.\nThey have declared war on you.  Those who want land next to you have written in their state constitutions demands for your destruction.\nWhat\'s the answer");
AddReply(437310,"But Whose Goose Is Being Cooked","dav lev","Burbank. CAUSA","05/15/09","To Andrew, Get Real: If blacks, Asians, Hispanics, women, widgets were so maligned and infuriorated, do you think they would remain silent? Whenh Muslims see cartoons, they riot and murder people. Iran, No. Korea, Cuba, Venezuela, etc., do not have ardent and emotional supporters in on our college campuses. We see how THEY protest in their home countries. Perhaps you would prefer we Jews start villifying Christ and everything surrounding your pagan religion...get my point, for the nonsense it really is. ");
AddReply(437306,"6m Germans Died To Kill 250,000 Jews","dav lev","Burbank CaUSA","05/15/09","When I was at a university, dorm members typically posted signs about Christianity. I loathed them, but could do nothing..free speech and all that. Of course the good professor could have done similarly, and distributed equivalent emails., showing Arabs beheading Jews, etc. Hmmm, I wonder sometimes how blacks would react if they were so maligned? Would they remain quiet? How would Asians and HIspanics react. The EEOC is worthless, mostly avoiding real conflict and handling easy cases. Or the mafia old fashioned way might have done more good. In Germany, there are rules about Hitler...but 70m people had to die before that country got it, including 6m Germans (to kill 250,000 German Jews). ");
AddReply(437203,"To #12 Comparisons are not \"valid\" simply because they are made","ZIggy","Safed","05/15/09","The Arabs are not experiencing genocide but population growth. The Arabs are not democratic. The Arabs murder their own, not jsut Jews. Israel does not exterminate Arabs but trues to make peace with them. This commuist moron who knows nothing about Judaism spreads the Big Lie about the JEws to help the Arabs destroy their nation. He used his position as a faculty member to indoctrinate. He should be fired. ");
AddReply(437033,"Hey Andy","Big Eye","Frozen Tundra","05/15/09","Tell me, how do you feel about Brett Farve potentially going to the Vikings.  If you are like most Packer fans you feel betrayed.  This Robinson\'s comparisons with the Warsaw Ghetto in my estimation cannot and should not be made to impressionable minds just because he holds some inferiority/superiority complex about himself as a Jew.  He sees his ego as more important than the Jewish People much as that schmuck Farve takes his bitterness towards Ted Thompson and sees himself as bigger and more important than the Packer fans, the organization or the game itself. Go Packers, w/o BF.  ");
AddReply(436970,"Analogies and Hypocrisy","Andrew","USA","05/15/09","The comparison wasn\'t fradulent at all.  The comparison is appropriate and quite accurate in its main points.  There are differences, of course.  Robinson will be the first to tell you that no historical comparison is perfectly analogous. But you will be hard pressed to find a better historical analog. And you won\'t find any that better illustrates the hypocrisy of Israel policy. And this is, after all, what has apologists for Israel so exercised. This is why it is so important to smear Robinson and intimidate others who would draw similar apt historical analogies.");
AddReply(436944,"rebuttal","Bruce S. Ticker","Philadelphia","05/14/09","Andrew: I usually do not respond to comments on my article. Robinson is entitled to his opinion and I am not afraid to debate him or any other critic of Israel. The drawback here is that he tried to impose his opinion on students who were vulnerable to his authority over them. Campus employees could make a case that he created a \"hostile environment.\" If he could not see that, he has a big blind spot that brings into question his judgment. At worst, he intentionally bullied his students. ");
AddReply(436906,"Andrew the comparisons were totally fraudulent!","Jew","Israel","05/14/09","");
AddReply(436818,"Anti-Jewish? Lying?","Andrew","Green Bay","05/14/09","How is what Robinson said anti-Jewish?  When did he lie?  He made a historical comparison.  Historical comparisons are more or less accurate. Making historical comparisons is not lying.  Comparison the basis of science.");
AddReply(436774,"Moshe","Cynthia","Ny","05/14/09","You are absolutely correct!It is incitement.\n\nSociology is a nasty discipline created as a forum for Marxism. They are liberals!\n\nShalom");
AddReply(436759,"Dayeinu!","Mike","Vienna, VA","05/14/09","And if tomorrow they decide that swastikas are PC while the3 Magen David is not, will they come and fire Jews for having an Israeli flag in their cubicle?  The EEOC and all the rest of the PC police have no business existing in a free society.  If this professor Robinson wants to be a Jewish antisemite, that\'s his business.  Under American law, he has a right to free speech. ");
AddReply(436691,"I saw the photos sent out by this clown","Ziggy","Safed","05/14/09","The photos that purported to show \"genocide\" by Israe of the Arabs were mostly shots of the checkpoints where terrorists are kept out. Meanwhile, the photo next to it showed Jews in the Warsaw Ghetto or on their way to the ovens in Aushwitz. Using this jerk\'s logic, we are all genocide victims when we stand in checkpoints at airports before boarding airplanes. Jewish anti-Semites are the worst anti-Semites. The mentally ill seek tenured positions where they can lie and indoctrinate.\nVisit this website: www.isracampus.org.il .");
AddReply(436657,"Andrew, criticism is allowed, lying is not","Jew","Israel","05/14/09","Gaza is similar to the Warsaw ghetto? Israel sent in hundreds of truckloads of food, medicine, fuel and other supplies to the Arabs in Gaza, even when Sederot was bombarded with Kassam missiles. Concerning checkpoints, the number of checkpoints grew as the number of suicide bombers and other terrorists did. Did any Jew in Germany ever attack his host country?");
AddReply(436533,"incitement, not free speech","moshe","Israel","05/14/09","This is not a \"free speech\" issue; rather it is anti-Jewish bigotry and incitement. That is an issue for the University to deal with as a public corporate body with by-laws, etc. \nWhere is ADL?\n ");
AddReply(436525,"Professor?","Michael Ackerman","BklynToBoca","05/14/09","Every despotic regime has/had professors: Saudi Arabia; Iran, Egypt, China (all today). Germany, Japan (wartime 1940\'s). Are we to assume this person is sane just because he holds a doctorate? If I were paying tuition to send my son of daughter to this cesspool of \'higher learning\' that would add insult to injury.  ");
AddReply(436443,"Israel Bashing","Andrew","Green Bay","05/14/09","Do you say the same thing about academics criticizing Iran, North Korea, or the former Soviet Union. I bet you don\'t.  I bet it never even crossed your mind.  \n\nOne either disagrees with a criticism and shows why it\'s wrong or one admits they have no rebuttal and cries \"Israel bashing\" or \"anti-Semitism,\" or some other such nonsense. \n\nI disagree with a lot of the propaganda about Cuba and Venezuela, but you never hear me crying \"Cuba bashing\" or Venezuela bashing.\"  \n\nRobinson and every other social scientists in a free and open society is at liberty to mount any criticism of any nation-state they believe advances the education of their students.  \n\nIf criticism of nation-states is \"bashing,\" what\'s wrong with bashing? \n\nIt\'s a real mark of your character that you used the EEOC procedure to harass a colleague with whom you disagreed politically. The tactic says: I fear debate.");
AddReply(436428,"get an attorney, go to court.","terry","","05/14/09","");

WriteReplies(1,8779,iDiv);