sRepliesHTML = "";iReplies = 33;mReplies = iReplies;iDiv = 6138
AddReply(63187,"Love thy Neighbor, share, Fairness.","Ed Rachanski","USA","04/18/06","Dear Israeli\'s, I really would like to visit Jeruseleum, but I can\'t, because of your situation with fighting all the time. If it could happen, I wish Rabin was back, a man who wanted peace, but look what your people did to him. America only supports you, not Palestine, do you honestly think the world will except this imbalance? Never. I truly wish you Peace as all of us are Children of the Creator. Professor Mearsheimer is truly an Honest fair Scholar with great political savey, I firmly believe he would not publish lies or mistruths on purpose, he is not that kind of man.  Thank You.");
AddReply(63186,"one man\'s food...","maahaadave","hana, maui","04/12/06","Jared you wrote: \" In my comments, I called Gil-White a \"would be Messiah..(Jewish \"ingratitude\" is, according to Hyam Maccoby, the basis of antisemitism\" If someone acts against his own economic interest because he feels he has something important to say which can help others normally people might call that path noble or naive or foolhardy. You claim to have the real insight. Prove it. As for the source of antisemitism it is propaganda. All anitsemitism throughout history has been created through the spread of propaganda. All hate is spread through propaganda for the purpose of exploitation.");
AddReply(63185,"I have the feeling its just you and me reading these...","Alex Weinstein","Philadelphia","04/12/06","Jared, Francisco has NOT attacked all Jewish leaders. He has only attacked those Jewish leaders who attack the Jewish people, and he\'s defended those who \ndefend the Jewish people. His piece on the WWII leaders loudly defends Bergson and Jabotinsky. In other words, he is defending us from our leaders who do us harm, and that\'s it.");
AddReply(63184,"Demagoguery rather then intelligent dialogue?","Maahaadave","hana,maui","04/12/06","Jared you wrote this about Francisco: \"Again this fits his view that \"Jews find it difficult to think rationally about their self defense\". That quote was in the context of how \"the peace movement\" in Israel was and is living in a self defeating dreamland of wishful thinking. Right fter he made that statement he wrote this: \"Jewish author Kenneth Levin has recently made the latest addition to a large literature that tries to understand this general problem\". He gives a link to a footnote which cites Levin\'s book \"The Oslo syndrome: Delusions of a people under siege\". ");
AddReply(63183,"Alex, your answer again supports my point","Jared Israel","Newton, MA","04/12/06","I wrote that while misrepresenting himself as an extension of tenc.net Gil-White displays unpredictably unreliable scholarship and an antisemitic world view, expressed in his thesis that Jews are especially incapable of self defense and his claim that because he rejected phony British resettlement schemes \"Rabbi Wise got his wish\" with the Shoah. http://tinyurl.com/nbsom You answer again that Gil-White is a martyr. Again this fits his view that \"Jews find it difficult to think rationally about their self defense\" and that he, martyred discoverer of the \"crux of world history\" is new messiah.");
AddReply(63182,"Disappointed","Alex Weinstein","Philadelphia","04/11/06","Jared you seem really set on attacking Dr. Gil-White for, lets see - losing his job (and all prospects of another one), being attacked in the mainstream press, getting labeled as crazy by a large proportion of the student body... all of which occurred as a result of his brave determination to do some good for the world (specifically for the Jewish people). I fail to grasp why you have such a problem with that. Does somebody doing a good deed at great expense to themselves justify you attacking them? I assumed you were one of the good guys. Now I\'m confused and disappointed.");
AddReply(63181,"Alex Weinstein Tells the Truth about Gil-White","Jared Israel","Newton, MA","04/10/06","Defending Francisco Gil-White, Alex Weinstein says that he \"never met anyone more willing to sacrifice himself for us more than he.\" In my comments, I called Gil-White a \"would be Messiah.\" Alex may not know that the Christian (not Jewish) concept of Messiah is a Godly fellow who sacrifices all for humanity, first for the (ungrateful) Jews. (Jewish \"ingratitude\" is, according to Hyam Maccoby, the basis of antisemitism.) Viewing himself as most \"willing to sacrifice himself for us,\" the Catholic Gil-White attacks Jewish leaders as viciously as possible, to be replaced with his personality cult.");
AddReply(63180,"Gil-White anti-Semitic?","Alex Weinstein","Philadelphia","04/09/06"," Those of you who claim Dr. Gil-White is anti-Semitic are way, way, way off base. I\'ve never heard anyone praise the Jewish people more than he; never heard anyone espouse the virtues of our religion more than he; never met anyone more willing to sacrifice himself for us more than he. If you claim he is anti-Semitic based on his conclusions you\'ve either misread or misinterpreted his pieces. Dr. Gil-White is absolutely not anti-Semitic, so if one of his articles attacks the AIPAC or other Jewish leaders its because they\'re harming Jews with their policy. ");
AddReply(63179,"Gil-White\'s attack on AIPAC","Nadia Jacobi","Vienna, Austria","04/09/06","I read Jared Israel?s statements. I then did some surfing on Gil-White\'s website. Disturbingly, I found that last year Francisco Gil-White wrote a very long article viciously attacking AIPAC. Why would someone who claims to defend Jews attack AIPAC exactly at the time when the US government was framing them on spying charges? He says nothing in that article about the anti-Semitic witch hunt launched against AIPAC. Gil-White does not mention, let alone apologise, for his attack on AIPAC, in the article above. Here is the URL of his anti-AIPAC article http://www.hirhome.com/israel/aipac.htm");
AddReply(63178,"Jared....please.","Maahaadave","hana, maui","04/08/06","Jared you wrote:\n\n\"even antisemitic conclusions. E.g., he claims Jewish leaders preferred Shoah to supposed offer to resettle Jews \"\n\nHow is that an anti-semitic claim? I find your throwing around the anti-semitic slur based on Gil-White\'s historical claims to be lamentable. Since you choose to label him with a slur I have to wonder why you chose to do so. Your remarks here about Gil-White have been demagogic. Instead of calling him names and disparaging his character and research in a demagogic manner maybe you could be more professional and less shallow in your critique of him? ");
AddReply(63177,"Gil-White\'s attack on AIPAC","Nadia Jacobi","Vienna, Austria","04/07/06","I read Jared Israel?s statements and did some surfing on Francisco Gil-White\'s web-site. Disturbingly, I found that last year Francisco Gil-White wrote a very long article viciously attacking AIPAC.  Why would someone who claims to defend Jews attack AIPAC exactly at the time when the U.S. was framing them on spying charges? He says nothing in that article about the anti-Semitic witch hunt launched against AIPAC.  Gil-White does not mention, let alone apologize, for his anti- AIPAC article in the article above.  Here is the URL of his attack on AIPAC http://www.hirhome.com/israel/aipac.htm");
AddReply(63176,"RAe: Ummm, Jared....","Jared Israel","Newton, Massachusetts","04/06/06","You criticize me here so I\'ll answer here. If you want a personal reply please write privately. I never said Jewish leaders are exempt from criticism. See Eden Natan-Zada article http://www.israelnationalnews.com/article.php3?id=5430 Gil-White claims Rabbi Wise wanted 6 million dead, hence rejected PHONY Brit land offer. That?s not ?criticism?, it?s the same as the antisemite claim that Zionists wanted holocaust. Gil-White claims to be my disciple (?!) Having read his piece praising Brits and slandering Jews, and seeing that he named me again, here, I chose (like you) to use this public forum.");
AddReply(63175,"ok felonous monk","Goldberg","","04/06/06","There is truth and there is reality. Jews might have the second largest/strongest lobby in DC but if you will look at the actions of of the US state department over the last 55 years, you will see that the US has treated Israel as a red headed step child would be treated. BTW, nice handle. it would imply that you are a felon and a member of the catholic church, a pervert priest perhaps? take your obvios hatred for the Jewish people and Israel, and shove it up your a**");
AddReply(63174,"Ummm, Jared....","Nigel W","Melbourne, Australia","04/06/06","I fail to see anything constructive in what you\'ve done here. If you really have a problem with Francisco\'s work, then you should write a rebuttal on EC rather than white-ant his exposure of antisemitic undercurrents here. If there\'s any truth to your assertions about FGW, it is obscured by your reliance here on logical fallacies. See http://www.nizkor.org/features/fallacies/\nWhy are \"Jewish Leaders\" exempt from criticism? \nThere\'s much more I\'d like to say but there\'s limited comment space. Email me on Changeling_au_2004@yahoo.com.au if you\'d like to have a chat about this.Sad2CU2have split");
AddReply(63173,"Re: SO JARED","Jared Israel","Newton, MA","04/05/06","I never before objected to anybody linking to www.emperors-clothes.com But Gil-White, whose writing I once edited/rewrote, now parades me as foundation of his \'great discoveries\' which combine stuff gleaned from Emperor?s Clothes, unpredictably unreliable scholarship, even antisemitic conclusions. E.g., he claims Jewish leaders preferred Shoah to supposed offer to resettle Jews by \"well-meaning\" Chamberlain & MacDonald. (Today he erased \"well-meaning\" from his text.)  I have only my good name so I clarify:  it was my decision that this would-be Messiah was removed from www.emperors-clothes.com");
AddReply(63172,"Hopefully the Jewish people will heed this warning!","Ryan Victor","Philadelphia","04/05/06","I sincerely hope they do. See the author\'s website for other pieces. http://www.hirhome.com");
AddReply(63171,"Mostly right, but not about Oslo","Shalom Freedman","Jerusalem Israel","04/05/06","This piece is mostly right but not about Oslo. Oslo was done behind the Americans\' back by Beilin- Peres and company. It is also not fair to ascribe to the United States all Israeli policy mistakes. ");
AddReply(63170,"So, JARED:","DOV","Poriya/Sarasota","04/04/06","Did or did you not write that article?  If Gil-White sites Your(?) article does that automatically mean you totally agree with him?  Does that mean You are offended because he found value in Your(?) article and sites it?  Or should he just have \"stolen\" the article, used it to reinforce his thesis/opinion/facts and NOT given the recognition to it that it is due?  WELL?");
AddReply(63169,"Now I get it...","Felonious Monk","","04/04/06","Now I get it: the opposite is the truth. Now it all makes sense. When Walt and Mearsheimer said black, they really meant white, and when they said day, they really meant night. Thanks for pointing that out to me. I knew it couldn\'t possibly be true that Israelis/Jews--who make up less than 5% of the US population--have the 2nd strongest political lobby in the US. Everyone who says so must be lying! And the people who complain that  our overall media coverage is biased towards Israel\'s Jewish population, they\'re lying too. Whenever we want the truth we\'ll just wait for Isreal to tell us. Thanks");
AddReply(63168,"Clarification: I reject link to Francisco Gil-White","Jared Israel","Newton, MA","04/04/06","Gil-White cites me above and on his website; I wish no association. Starting from info about Jewish errors in WWII gleaned from PBS http://tinyurl.com/e6ju7 his site http://tinyurl.com/nbsom goes off the deep end attacking WWII Jewish leaders, claiming that when 6 million died, leader \"Rabbi Wise [AJC] got his wish.\" He lauds Malcolm (British White Paper) McDonald, tormenter of Jews, saying he desperately tried to settle Jews in Africa but Jews coldly sabotaged him. Gil-White targets Rothschild, favorite of Catholic antisemites. He hides his Jew-baiting behind a pose of more-Jewish-than-Jews.");
AddReply(63167,"Strange reasoning","Rowan Berkeley","London, England","04/04/06","So what you are saying, Francisco, is : because the US was able to resist the Jewish demand to smash up the entire near East until Shrub came to power, therefore, there is no Jewish lobby?");
AddReply(63166,"Wake-up call","Norman Cohen","Los Angeles, California","04/04/06","The way that the world works is that facts and logic will never sway  minds which are made up.\nRather than preach to the choir, we need to recognize that the atmosphere in the USA is changing and that a kernel of truth is all that\'s necessary to lay groundwork for evil. It\'s a wake-up call for us to be alert to and to prepare ourselves so that we don\'t repeat mistakes of the past.  ");
AddReply(63165,"Thank you Klaus!","","","04/04/06","you have proven the point that these so called educators are no more than lefty liberal antisemites.");
AddReply(63164,"toronto whining","","","04/04/06","aint it interesting that a great many of the babbling idiots hail from toronto?");
AddReply(63163,"OK Fransisco,  but reality defies logic","Rob","USA","04/04/06","The underlying cause of racial conflict and also the antisemitism displayed by overly educated morons like these fellows are, 1. going to a secular university and learning we came from apes and played with our own dung. 2. that man is NOT! the very apex of G-Ds creation and therefore the Jewish people are not G-Ds chosen who shall proclaim HIS NAME to the nations BUT! the fact is, they are most certainly HIS chosen and beloved. against all odds they have survived the yoke of egypt and rome, the inqusitions and pogroms, nazi death camps, not to mention the miracles from 1948 to present day.");
AddReply(63162,"The Three Billion Dollars Per Year","The Learned Elders Of Zio","Houston, Texas","04/04/06","At the conclusion of the Egypt-Israel peace treaty(bad joke, actually), the agreement called for the payment of U.S. foreign aid to each party: $3 billion to Israel and 2 billion to Egypt.  It took that on the part of Egypt to get it to accept the agreement.  Have a nice day.");
AddReply(63161,"Klaus wrong","Marshall","Milwaukee","04/03/06","  Israel clearly stated on numerous occasions before the war that it considered Iran to be its primary enemy and far far greater than Iraq and Saddam.\n  Israel had taken care of Saddam\'s threat in the early 1980\'s when it destroyed its nuclear reactor.\n   Proof of this is the current situation. Iraq as it turned out was a paper tiger and Iran is the middle east nuclear threat such that now the entire world including your Germany is trying to get Iran to give up its nuclear weapons.\n  The current facts of history prove Klaus obviously and totally wrong. \n  ");
AddReply(63160,"From with-in","Carl van Zijll de Jong","Lincoln NZ","04/03/06","Dear Sir, Your article is beautiful written. However, it would be good to focus on the forces that works from with-in Israel. The forces which are at work to corrupt the minds of Israel?s population by providing falls information and communicating a concept of guilt. It would be good to devote your skills by pointing-out who these people are, and how to remedy them. Kind regards, Carl +. ");
AddReply(63159,"Second biggest recipient of US aid: Egypt","Yonatan","Los Angeles","04/03/06","The morons (ahem) \"authors\" seem to gloss over that fact. Carter lovingly set up US payments to Egypt as bribe money to maintain the Camp David Accord and not attack Israel. However, Egypt is using the money to rearm.");
AddReply(63158,"Acadaemia Weighs in With Some Big Lies","Moshe Finberg","Boulder, Colorado","04/03/06","The Walt \"Study\" is an indication of how dangerous things are becoming in the U.S. for Jews.  Like the Nazis before them, those who seek to destroy the Jewish People today have enlisted university professors to give their anti-Semitism the appearance of intellectual integrity.  Thank you Professor for helping to explode their myths.  This must be shown to the people.  ");
AddReply(63157,"AIPAC Whining","Dovy","Toronto","04/03/06","Isn\'t amazing the way people run to pick through a report that speaks the truth, whereas they constantly ignore the lies and fantasies of the Zionist propaganda machine, or of the drug-trafficking Mossad and IDF?!");
AddReply(63156,"Excellent article -- also see author\'s website","Dan","Jerusalem","04/03/06","Israel would be able to defend itself, would earn billions more from military sales if not for U.S. military support (& Egypt would not be armed to the teeth)");
AddReply(63155,"Iraq war for Israel\'s security","Klaus Bloemker","Frankfurt, Germany","04/03/06","On Januaray 26, 2003, there was an interview in the Frankfurter Allgemeine Sonntagszeitung (the Sunday paper of Germany\'s leading conservative-liberal daily). The interviewee was Ruth Wedgwood (professor of International Law at Yale and Johns Hopkins and a member of the Pentagon\'s Defense Policy Board).\n\nThe interviewer asked: \"How would you convince me to say \'yes\' to the war against Iraq?\"\nWedgwood replied:\"I could be impolite and remind Germany of its special relationship with Israel. Saddam poses an existential threat to Israel. This is simply so.\"\n");

WriteReplies(1,6138,iDiv);