Dutch woman punished for anti-Zionist conspiracy theory can sue

Court rules that Dutch Justice Ministry employee who was suspended for saying Zionists invented ISIS can sue for damages.

Contact Editor
Arutz Sheva Staff and JTA,

Flag of the Netherlands
Flag of the Netherlands
iStock

A Dutch Justice Ministry employee who was suspended and threatened with termination for saying that Zionists invented the Islamic State (ISIS) terrorist group can sue for damages, a judge has ruled.

Yasmina Haifi, a former senior cybersecurity specialist, was “too harshly punished” for making a statement that is protected by freedom of speech, according to the ruling last week by a magistrate in The Hague, which was reported by JTA.

The decision came three years after Haifi was suspended from her National Cyber Security Center post for writing on Twitter that “ISIS has nothing to do with Islam. It’s part of a plan by Zionists who are deliberately trying to blacken Islam’s name.”

She was then readmitted as a ministry employee in a different position and warned she would be fired if she continues to express herself in a manner deemed extremist, according to JTA.

In a lawsuit against the ministry for abusing her rights as an employee, Haifi said the probation made her feel “muzzled” and that she had no prospects for advancement at the ministry, NRC Handelsblad reported.

The judge, ruling that Haifi may take her case to a labor court, said a written reprimand would have sufficed. The ruling also stated that Haifi, who removed the message from Twitter soon after she posted it, “received much negative publicity” because “opinion shapers, media and columnists jumped on the issue.”

Haifi complained last year to the College for Human Rights, a government watchdog, that she was singled out for disciplinary action because of her origins, which are Muslim. A petition calling for her dismissal from the ministry titled “Say No to Anti-Semitism in Dutch Politics” received 1,322 signatures.

She has denied accusations in the media that her remark was anti-Semitic, insisting that she merely had expressed her views on the “supporters of an ideology.”

After her suspension, Haifi initially said she would not take back her statements because she has the right to speak her mind.

Later, however, she removed the statement from her Twitter feed and said, “I realize the political sensitivity in relation to my work. This [public reaction] was never my intention.”