Nisan 28, 5769, 4/22/2009
COMPLACENCY

Yishai, Shalom,
Do Mike and sk really support Israel (i.e. the people of Israel, not necessarily the regime)?
Can someone who claims to support Israel, be at the same time an anti-Aliyah advocate.
I can accept any criticism of the Israeli government and Israelis, but where I draw the line is :
1) inciting Israelis to commit violent acts against other Jews
2) discouraging people from making Aliyah.
The left in Israel does not want American Aliyah! Because who would make Aliyah? Mostly American Jews who are religious and right-wing. If they wanted American Aliyah, they would know very well how to promote it, just as the Jewish agency went all over Russia looking for goyim to move to Israel, and gave special grants to them.
Mike and sk do not have a real argument, that is why they revert to ad hominem attacks against those who disagree with them. Isn't it obvious that nothing positive will come from their calls for violence, only an excuse for the regime to clamp down.
Nor do they understand the real problem, that there are two kind of religious Zionists:
1) Land of Israel faithful who voted for the National Union
2) Bourgeois "mamlachti" religious Zionists, who read Haaretz and look up to the Tzfonim and voted for the Bayit Yehudi.
The most important mission of the land of Israel activists is to move the bourgeois religious Zionists from their comfy chairs.
Frankly, I am tired of them and wish they would just go away. All the effort you put into promoting aliyah -- you could have had a lucrative career defending white-collar criminals on Wall St. -- and these two attempt to spoil it.
As for your blog, I think your positive stories about the Jewish people returning to their land are exciting, but they don't seem to move some of your readers very much.
I think you ought to "challenge" your readers more, shake them out of their complacency. Perhaps, write more about the decline of Jewish life in America ?
* Moslems moving into traditional Jewish neighborhoods. And they are everywhere, so no point in moving from Passaic to Highland Park to Princeton.
* the Federal Government promoting a radical, leftist agenda, i.e. children reading "I have two mommies" in school or allowing gay marriage in certain states.
People in Monsey, should not think they can hide from this in their ghettoes. The Federal gov't can force this on them through federal funding of schools, "sensitivity training" at work, and many other ways.
Yes, there is decadence in Israel, but it's not so much enshrined in the law books.
* the anti-Israel, anti-semitic environment on campus. You have begun to address this issue, but perhaps it deserves more attention.
* The US government's hostility to Israel and support for the terrorists. American Jews should think twice about residing in a country which supports the Jewish peoples' enemies.
* Who is more Jewish: Israeli secular Jews or American reform Jews. I have seen apparently secular Jews reading tehillim on the bus. Can you imagine a reform Jew in America reading tehillim?
*************************************
I enjoyed the podcast about global warming
Article about Al Gore
http://www.canadafreepress.com/2007/cover031307.htm
"... both [Maurice] Strong and Gore are cashing in on the lucrative cottage industry known as man-made global warming." (article goes on to explain how they have businesses which engage in selling carbon credits, etc.)
"... that Gore and Strong have made climate change 'the new religion'. ...Along with former Soviet Union leader Mikhail Gorbachev, [Maurice] Strong, currently president of the Earth Council, has been boasting of replacing the Ten Commandments with the Earth Charter, a golden rule guide for how the masses should treat the environment.
"Gore, who has given sermons at the United Nations sponsored Cathedral of St. John the Divine Church in New York City, is a promoter of the religion known as Gaia.
"The two environmental gurus also share a belief in radical Malthusian population reduction. According to them, too many people, particularly in the U.S. are polluting the planet, emitting excessive Freon through their refrigerators and jacking up the air conditioning.
B'kitzur, I have nothing against preserving the environment, we should just be careful not to be manipulated by people with a different agenda such as Al Gore and Maurice Strong.
In fact, the perhaps most important environmental issue is GMO foods or "Frankenfood", i.e. putting a pig gene in corn, more or less ignored by the American media.
Why do we need Al Gore to tell us what to do ?
Wouldn't we be better off looking to the Torah for guidance, i.e. bal tashchit, but let's stick to what the halachah says, instead of treating every word from Al Gore as Torah m'-Sinai, especially given that environmentalism is tainted with Avodah Zara, nature worship.
In the case of GMO, there is the prohibition of kilayim, mixing species.
kol tuv, Dan