Visible Tzitzis (Tassels)
Some time ago, I wrote about complaints voiced by IDF soldiers against their officers who ordered them to tuck
Such an order runs counter to the Torah.
their tzitzis (fringes) into their pants. Such an order runs counter to the Torah, which rules that the tzitzis should be ever viewable because they remind us at all times of our Torah obligations. It is thus written , “That you may look upon it, and remember all the commandments of the Lord, and do them; and that you seek not after your own heart and your own eyes, which incline you to go astray.” (Numbers 15:39)

True, Kabbalistic works state, in the name of the holy ARI, that the tallit (small four-cornered garment) should be worn as an undergarment, but the Magen Avraham (8:13) explains that this ruling applies specifically to the garment; the tassels, however, must be visible. And he adds that it is very unlikely that one who keeps his tzitzis covered has actually fulfilled the commandment.

The soldiers continue, thank God, to fulfill this Torah commandment, and their tzitzis hang freely from their uniform for all to see, despite various threats.

The Sephardic Custom
Yet, I was asked: It is well known that the Sephardic custom is to wear the tzitzis under one's clothing (as Rabbi Ovadia Yosef rules in Yachveh Daat 2:1). Why, then, did I not state that my ruling applies to Ashkenazi Jews alone?

Answer: First of all, it should be pointed out that this is the ruling of Rabbi Yosef Karo (Shulchan Aruch, Orach Chaim 8:11): “Basically, the mitzvah of wearing a small tallit involves wearing it over one’s garments, so that one will see it continually and remember the mitzvot (commandments).” Furthermore, our mentor, Rabbi Tzvi Yehudah HaCohen Kook, head of the Mercaz HaRav Yeshivah, would encourage his students to wear their tzitzis outside of their clothing, and he made no distinction between Sephardic and Ashkenazic Jews.

However, I was told by Rabbi David Chai HaCohen, one of Rabbi Tzvi Yehudah's leading students, that he once asked Rabbi Tzvi Yehudah if his ruling to wear tzitzis outside of one's garments applied to him as well, for his family's custom (Rabbi David Chai HaCohen's uncle was an important Torah scholar and a faithful follower of the Ben Ish Chai) was to wear tzitzis under their garments. Rabbi HaCohen told me that it was clear to him that he would abide by whatever ruling Rabbi Tzvi Yehudah gave. Rabbi Tzvi Yehudah told him that he did not have to wear his tzitzis outside of his clothing. Based upon this ruling, Rabbi David Chai HaCohen instructs his Sephardic students to wear their tzitzis under their clothing.

However, in my own humble opinion, it appears to be proper, today, even according to Sephardic custom, to wear one's tzitzis outside of one's clothing. This is because, in previous generations, North African and Eastern Jewry were accustomed to wearing a kind of large shawl which did not allow them to cover their tallit and at the same time display their tzitzis. They had to choose between wearing their entire tallit on top of their clothing, revealing everything (in accordance with Shulchan Aruch) or to conceal everything (in accordance with the holy ARI), and they adopted the latter path.

Today, though, we all wear shirts and pants, and there is no problem concealing the tallit while at the same time
There is great value in wearing the tzitzis outside of one's clothing, for by doing this a person expresses his allegiance to the Torah.
revealing the tzitzis, fulfilling the commandment according to all opinions. And this would actually appear to be the opinion of the Holy ARI, for he writes that a person must look at his tzitzis frequently during the course of the day (Shaar HaKavanot 7:3). My own humble opinion is that because over the generations people became accustomed to concealing both tallit and tzitzis, many continue this practice even today. However, in truth, it is proper to wear the tzitzis outside of one's clothing.

Furthermore, practically speaking, there is great value in wearing the tzitzis outside of one's clothing, for by doing this a person expresses his allegiance to the Torah and its commandments, and he is reminded to perform the commandments. This is in keeping with the plain meaning of the verse, “That you may look upon it, and remember all the commandments of the Lord, and do them.”

In a secular environment, at work or in the army, it is very important for an observant Jew to wear something which shows that he is meticulous about fulfilling the commandments and that he is not ashamed to perform them in the presence of people who are liable to make fun of him. By doing this, it becomes easier for him to endure trials.

A person who dresses in a Haredi ("ultra-Orthodox") fashion, with a black hat and suit, is less in need of this distinction, for all can see by his clothing that he is Haredi. In the army, however, this changes; the tzitzis become important because everybody wears the same uniform. In the workplace, as well, it is very important for a Jew to make himself distinct through his tzitzis, the unique garment which the Torah commands us to wear.

Conclusion
Even if a person generally upholds the Sephardic custom (which goes back to the time when Sephardic Jews would dress in long shawls) of wearing his tzitzis under his clothing, when serving in the army it is best to wear one's tzitzis outside of one's clothing, in a manner that they be clearly visible. The only time one must tuck them in is during camouflaged training and, of course, while carrying out operations in enemy territory.

Send comments or questions for Rabbi Melamed to Yonaton Behar at yonatonb@yahoo.com.